Bring behind Rafizi.
We had perhaps been spoiled by Khairy Jamaluddin's before debate, with Rafizi Ramli in London the little months ago. There, the dual debaters -- upon conflicting sides of the parliamentary divide, as well as dedicated to vanquishing the other's celebration in GE13 -- were polite, respectful, jovial, as well as intelligent. While you awarded the discuss to Khairy upon points, you appreciated Rafizi's tone, approach, as well as concrete approach.
Dato' Ambiga Sreenevasan could sense the thing or dual from Rafizi.
We have been discussing, of course, The Malay Mail's Spark the Debate, held in between Ambiga as well as Khairy. Although the discuss began upon friendly conditions -- after the painfully long array of introductions -- the debaters had the brief impulse of warn during the musical choice The Malay Mail chose to proceed the discuss -- though the dual debaters' sides fast coalesced.
Ambiga began with her usual, somewhat stilted, though dynamic recitation of the same census data Bersih as well as Pakatan Rakyat -- insofar as there is the poignant difference -- have been report for the little time. Phantom voters, dead voters, electorate over 100. She showed initial flashes of humour, as well as during first seemed to take this as the frank discuss upon the issues. She was really classical Ambiga: Staid, solid, determined. She but claimed which there was widespread voting fraud.
Khairy was his common self -- comfortable, relaxed, eschewing the notes which Dato' Ambiga clutched by her presentation. He asked because Bersih was dynamic to pre-empt the reforms the Parliamentary Select Committee had undertaken. He responded by agg! ressive the phantom voter issue. He remarkable which the Election Commission (EC) publicly advertised the 42,051 electorate who were dynamic to be questionable, broadcast them to the world, as well as asked them to come brazen -- as well as most did. He asked because this would be rascal if the Election Commission had broadcast those same numbers for months.
In short, he asked, again as well as again, because Bersih was dynamic to cry 'fraud,' when the Government as well as the EC were operative to residence the really reforms Bersih demanded.
It is here which Ambiga either mislaid her cool or let her facade slip. She found her romantic rhythm as well as began, "I'll tell you where the rascal lies," as well as began to recite most of her before points, including the purported transformation of electorate from their constituencies. She went upon in this vein for the little time, demanding the face-to-face with the EC and, apparently, the little MPs.
Khairy was again loose in response. He done the point written to answer dual Bersih demands during once. He remarkable which Tan Sri Khalid Ibrahim -- whom Bersih has used as an example of the switched-constituency demand -- had in truth had his subdivision changed. The Government had undertaken to make sure which the electoral boundaries were correct, using Google Earth, as well as had found they were not. They did not pierce someone out of the scold constituency, they corrected decades-old errors from when voters, like Khalid, had been mis-assigned.
Khalid's subdivision was additionally altered because he has not updated his residence given 1985, and, as Khairy remarkable to the little laughter, not only has he moved the little times given then, though he no longer resides in Petaling Jaya -- he is right away in Shah Alam.
From there, Ambiga's display as well as feeling degenerated. In reply to Khairy's calls to examination the EC's work as well as to actually encounter with them instead of having! press c onferences during them, Ambiga stated which she did not as well as could not certitude the EC. Khairy, in the little frustration, asked if Ambiga could not certitude the EC, because was Bersih demanding so most of them. For this, Ambiga had no direct answer.
Again as well as again, Khairy showed the smooth command of contribution as well as figures, including anecdotal evidence of most of the soft explanations for Bersih's claimed errors. (One revelation example was his partner receiving an ID card identifying him as the woman.) For this, Ambiga had no response.
Ultimately, after one more behind as well as forth, as well as after Khairy had offering the olive bend of stating which Ambiga was dissapoint with Pakatan hijacking Bersih, Ambiga could not move herself to treat with him levelly. She demanded which he guarantee the horde of reforms before GE13 (Khairy's response: "As most as you wish me to be the PM, I do not know when the elections are."). Her somewhat confused position was which the EC cannot be trusted, though which Bersih should have the palm in doing the work ... while assembly with them.
Perhaps zero sums up the night better than the conclusion. Khairy offering which each Malaysian longed for giveaway as well as satisfactory elections, as well as offering the olive bend of the joint examination of the electoral rolls during the EC. He was relaxed, though sincere, in job upon Malaysians to act as the people in solution this dispute.
Ambiga was stiff, as well as obviously dissapoint which she had not been able to overcome Khairy. She began by claiming which not each Malaysian longed for giveaway as well as satisfactory elections. She brought herself underneath better control by the finish -- shutting upon the last statement which she demanded the check in elections ("like in Bangladesh, where they delayed for the year") to purify up the electoral rolls.
The crowds were variable. Khairy's supporters were -- with the few hap! less exc eptions, such as when Ambiga closed with the demand to check elections for the year -- generally well-behaved, if overly enthused by Khairy's presentation. The Bersih crowd plainly booed as well as jeered Khairy during odd times throughout.
This discuss was never going to be as beguiling as the Khairy-Rafizi debate, as well as given Bersih's relative miss of importance, would never carry the same long-term import. But you had hoped for as most substance, as most seriousness, as most politeness.
We got it from Khairy. But not from Ambiga.
Read More @ Source More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Courtesy of Bonology.com Politically Incorrect Buzz & Buzz
No comments:
Post a Comment