Muezzin of Pahang state mosque killed in accident
Senior citizens in 'long march' hailed
An independent film executive has described a participation of senior citizens in a Himpunan Hijau impetus from Kuantan to Kuala Lumpur as a rise of civic awareness.
Tan Chui Mui (right), 32, who joined a marchers dual days ago, was astounded by a active participation of a series of senior citizens in a tiresome 300km trek.
"I consider Malaysians have changed a lot, we can't imagine myself saying uncles as well as aunties receiving a mount dual years ago. They right away know what they are doing," she toldMalaysiakini.
Tan, who was innate in a fishing encampment near Gebeng, Kuantan, opposed a Lynas singular earth processing plant that is located in her home town.
She has constructed a documentary film upon a debate opposite a plant, where most residents in a area have lifted fears of radioactive waste.
"This is partial of an awakening in civic awareness. Most people used to consider that a nation has zero to do with them, but right away they feel it's necessary to take a stand, as well as we am happy to see that."
Tan reached Maran upon Thursday night as well as began her impetus yesterday with some 80 activists. They walked a total of 31km prior to environment up camp in Temerloh.
Tan pronounced she decided to come back a couple o! f days e arlier from Beijing, China to stick on a march, prior to attending a commercial operation assembly in Kuala Lumpur scheduled next Tuesday.
"This is an interesting movement. Even yet it is very simple, it looks incredible."
Tan urged Malaysians to minister to a debate as they will face a outcome of a plant, a single approach or another.
"You must take partial as well as it can be in any form," she stressed.
Donation of socks
Meanwhile, a netizen drove from Kuala Lumpur during 3.30am yesterday to broach 100 pairs of socks sponsored by a in isolation association so that a marchers could strengthen their feet.
"Everyone is receiving part, so it's not right for me to stay during home. we too have to fool around my part," pronounced Suzzane Lau, who worked as sales assistant. Lau pronounced her trainer supported her decision.
The impetus was led by Himpunan Hijau chairperson Wang Tack to pressure a government to stop a Lynas singular earth plant, that is due to proceed operation soon.
Last Friday, a Kuantan High Court discharged an duplicate by 3 Gebeng residents to postpone a preference to grant a plant a proxy handling licence.
The marchers arrived in Temerloh last night after four days of marching, carrying about half of a journey.
They are expected to arrive during a gates of Parliament next Tuesday. The group additionally planned stopovers during Mentakab, Bentong as well as Genting Highlands along their approach to a capital. Read M ore @ Source
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
PAS true colours revealed as Welfare state is proven to be PAS hardline Islamic state
Health DG on leave pending action for khalwat offence
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Baik tidor Hadi ... Tak payah bincang hal luar negara
Ianya seolah-olah senario politik Malaysia sama dengan di Timur Tengah. malaysia tidak perlu diadakan kekecuhan dan peperangan untuk lakukan perubahan kerana pilihanraya sentaisa diadakan dan kerajaan sentaisa berubah dan peka tentang membawa kemajuan dan membaiki
'Beware of BNs plot to create rift among ourselves'
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Two pre-conditions for Pakatan Rakyat to beat Umno/Barisan Nasional in the battle for Putrajaya in the 13GE
Has Hisham lost control of the police force?
YOURSAY'The home apportion as well as his cousin, a PM, have been both still upon a purported rape. The military have been right away a law unto themselves.'
Police probe fresh Indonesian lassie abuse cases
Lamborghini:It is good as well as right which a supervision has condemned a rape of a Indonesian woman.
Rape is a single of a vilest acts of charge since it is carried out opposite a victim(s) only to satisfy a aggressor's lust. And generally when a victims have been considered easy, vulnerable targets.
While there is rightful outcry opposite a rape of Indonesians in Malaysia, since is there a no similar snub as well as action opposite therape of Penan girls as well as womenin Sarawak by a loggers?
Up compartment today, in spite of military reports as well as even admission by a government, not a single chairman has been held as well as convicted in court.
Are you promulgation out a summary which rape of unfamiliar women have been unsuitable since of possible domestic as well as economic repercussions, whilst rape of internal women is acceptable since they do not know their rights as well as have no voice, as well as you can only omit them as well as fake it did not happen?
Shanandoah:The home apportion as well as his cousin, a PM, have been both still upon this matter. Have they mislaid c! arry out of a military force?
Just look at a military hierarchy as well as you will assimilate since a military handle this way. They have been a law unto themselves. They have been stable no make a difference what laws they have broken.
Hang Tuah PJ:As a Malaysian, can you additionally criticism in front of a Indonesian Embassy in Malaysia about a thousands of bootleg Indonesians, many of whom have being going around robbing, raping as well as murdering Malaysians for a last integrate of decades as well as crowding us out of a tamans?
Odin:Hang Tuah PJ, you consider there is a big difference between a dual issues. The bootleg Indonesian immigrants exist since a Malaysian supervision in actuality encourages a influx - to swamp a so-called 'pendatangs' as well as emanate a pool of pro-BN voters.
That means a pronounced government, not a Indonesian government, is responsible for their misbehaviour as well as sinful acts. Should you wish to protest, you do so in front of a Home Minister's bureau as well as not a Indonesian Embassy.
My sum sympathy goes to a dual purported rape victims. The dastardly action is simply unforgivable, generally which a victims have been foreigners as well as a single of whom is only fifteen years young, as well as among a perpetrators have been military officers.
Foreigners must always be made to feel protected as well as be protected in this country. The cases must be investigated thoroughly, as well as a full force of a law exacted upon a suspects when convicted.
Anonymous #59879079:Why do these rape cases occur in Malaysia as well as you don't listen to most of such cases in Singapore?
Because law as well as sequence has damaged down in Malaysia whilst Singapore adopts a no-nonsense attitude in enforcing a law. The home apportion as well as inspector-general of military (I! GP) shou ld know what to do.
Whatsup:My heart goes out to a victims, as well as you reject a perpetrators - in fact, all perpetrators of criminal acts (be it hate-mongering, racism, etc).
Let's see how these dual cases unfold, as a latest case interestingly happened rught away after a first. Are there some-more than encounter a eyes?
Onyourtoes:My apologies to a Indonesian women who were raped. Whatever your resources now, you believe your chance of seeing probity rendered to those who committed wrong opposite you is improved than those who have raped a Penan women in Sarawak.
Spirit of Malaya:All this will not occur if a military force was truly independent. This is a result of a domestic masters interfering in a polite use as well as a military top coronet trying to damp a politicians in return for favours.
Let's not fake it doesn't exist. You can't change this inhuman complement any some-more - when your plant is filthy with parasites, a best thing to do is dig it as well as reinstate it with a brand new plant.
CiViC:That's a problem, as most as military officers consider they can get away with crime themselves, that's as most as any chairman thinks they can get away from a military for committing crime.
It is indeed right to contend notice plays a vital role here, a military have been viewed to be corrupt as well as have been criminals themselves, thus any Tom, Dick or Harry shall action as if there's no law.
Keturunan Malaysia:What you cannot stand have been a ones which roar as well as beat their chests about only how good as well as pristine they are, though in actuality a most lawless, some-more so when you entrusted and/or compensate them to safeguard a good as well as correct administration of law as well as order. These have been a scums of a earth.
Bystander:Whao, a same enforcement agency which is right away questioning this Indonesian lassie rape in Seremban is additionally being accused to have 3 of their officers committed an matching crime.
It is only same, same different. - Mal! aysiakini! Read More @ Source
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Indiscipline in the force going out of control
Three cops charged with 'gang rape'
Onyourtoes:I will not accept this case, if it ever goes upon trial, as an additional bad apple in a cart. Where did a military officers concerned find a boldness to allegedly do such a iniquitous thing in a military station?
Have they had no fright of their victims reporting a incident? Have they had no fright which they will be found out? Have they had no fright of a effect which they have to face?
I hold this boldness did not come from nothing. you consider it is not a coax of a moment thing. you consider it is calculated as well as planned.
I consider this box exemplifies a hardening of deviant poise after years of inaction upon bad fortify in a military force. you hold any military force with a smallest turn of decency will not do such a thing in a military station.
The environment up of a Independent Police Complaints as well as Misconduct Commission (IPCMC) is now some-more urgent than ever, as well as it is not for a military to decide.
James1067:There were thirty 'supporters' in probity as well as which as well from a military fratern! ity. What has turn of a military force?
The bad innocent Indonesian maid was allegedly gang raped as well as has left by a calamity as well as here you have 'supporters' display up in court. That additionally from a people who! have be en ostensible to strengthen a helpless.
Whatsup:No contrition during all for those who were in probity to uncover 'support' for these 3 purported rapists. It was all wrong meaningful how iniquitous rape is, worst of all, it was allegedly committed by military officers as well as in a really place where people should seek assistance or protection.
This is only a tip of a iceberg for sure based upon loads of version evidence, if a supervision care to investigate, assuming it is not in a know already.
As long as PDRM (Royal Malaysian Police) allow a powers-that-be to make use of them as personal thugs to harass as well as intimidate a open as well as opposition, opposite all common clarity as well as a law, such crimes by their members will never cease.
Enough is enough, IGP (inspector-general of police) as well as home apportion should bear full responsibility as well as step down.
Righteous officers, it's time to right a wrongs. Follow your conscience as well as religious teachings - there's no approach immorality can win unless you allow them.
Bystander:Frankly, there have been most such cases as well as this sold box which was reported is one of those during a tip of a iceberg.
It is a fact which most foreigners, generally those illegals who were caught overstaying similar to a most 'China dolls', would really mostly have to solve a matter around money or sex.
How could a aloft ranking officers not be aware of it? Remember a box of an Indonesian lady who was forced to have verbal sex with a little military officers whilst in custody a few years back?
I can't imagine those animals could do such things as well as some-more so in a military hire itself. How can you certitude a PDRM?
Anonymous_40c8:If found guilty, these 3 who have been ostensible to be keepers of a laws though instead law breakers, should be punished twice as severely.
If normal people break this law as well as have been ! sentence d to 10 years' jail, these 3 bad cops should serve 20 years. If it is a genocide sentence, afterwards they should be hanged twice - which is, after a first hanging, they should be hanged once more!
Wira:In ancient days in China, it was written in a imperial law books which those who were entrusted to uphold a law though broke it themselves should embrace a heavier penalty.
Babylon:Shouldn't a Syariah Court additionally be charging these military officers forkhalwator illicit sex by force. They deserve a severest of punishment. How this box is rubbed could well confirm my choosing by casting votes preference.
Nes:This is some-more than only a 3 military officers as well as not an isolated box of indiscipline in a force by a mile.
The fish rots from a head. The hearing and, perhaps, self-assurance of a military officers will only treat a sign not a cause. Indeed, a home apportion should be upon trial.
Tancc:This is a shameful p! roblem wi! th Umno's probity system. When underneath vigour from a unfamiliar country, a Umno probity complement functions fast. Remember theSquatgate- a suspected Chinese lady was forced to do naked squat as well as a video was leaked?
Under China's vigour afterwards PM Abdullah Ahmad Badawi had to send a apportion to Beijing to apologise as well as a royal commission of exploration (RCI) was shaped to examine a case, which later found out it was a internal Malay lady instead.
Anonymous_3ec6:Police officers sport for foreigners with a hazard of taking them to a military hire as well as extorting money from them is common. There is no professionalism in a force. It's a flaw to a nation.
< strong>DontPlayGod:Well, deaths have occurred in military stations, so what is rape? The military officers suspicion which they can get divided with it, only similar to in a other hundreds of cases.
Lionking:When Pakatan Rakyat comes in to Putrajaya, they must increase a salaries of a cops. Without correct benefits as well as salaries, a incident will not improve.
By a way, you do have a sizable amount of crime committed by foreigners as well as this is quite patently due to a miss of correct screening of foreigners as well as a boring attitude of a Malaysian officials.
RAW:Is a stealing of their faces a thoughtfulness of their guilt? Or is it given of any dubious reason which you do not know?
The purported rapists must be given a satisfactory trial, though in a interest of a public, photos display their faces should be published given they have been rigourously charged with their names revealed.
Yap CS:I suspicion all lock-ups have been suppose to be equipped with closed-circuit radio (CCTV)? Are they 'not working' again? - Malaysiakini
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Is the Indian community gullible?
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Reformasi: The big leap forward
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitic! s Plus |
Letupan di Himpunan Kebangkitan Rakyat Kelantan!! Ramai Orang Umno Cedera Tengok Gambar Ini!!! (DENGAN VIDEO)
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Hadi mahu tawan Putrajaya guna bohong dan fitnah
Ucapan dasar Hadi Awang di Muktamar PAS di Kota Baru semalam penuh retorik politik yang tertumpu kepada audience yang serba naif dan isu yang dibuat-buat dalam hal pentadbiran negara.
Tiada satu pun yang diucapnya mempunyai isu kandung yang boleh menyumbang kepada permasaalahan negara.
Dalam ucapan dasarnya yang bertajuk "Negara Kebajikan Teras Perpaduan",
The Selayang council chief was only TELLING THE TRUTH, can BN not accept that?
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Why are Malaysians living in the dark?
And the war beginsvia Twitter
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Dato Ramli Yusuf given a ceremonial farewell by PDRM
November 16, 2012
Comment by Din Merican
This morning we received around sms an call in from Dato Ramli Yusuf, former Director, Commercial Crime Investigation Department to inform me that a Royal Malaysian Police Force (PDRM) is giving him a formal farewell. He longed for to respect me as a single of a many Malaysians who had upheld him in his query for justice, as well as longed for me to attend a rite as his guest.
I felt we it was not compulsory for me to attend as we would have done a same thing for any Malaysian who is a plant of injustice. we did that for Lawyer Rosli Dahlan, as well as a 6 Police Officers who were victimized as well as charged in probity when Musa Hassan was Inspector-General of Police (IGP) for divulgence Musa's link to a crime syndicate in Johor Bahru.
When probity beckons, we Malaysians contingency come together to quarrel for a Rule of Law as well as Justice. Being unexcited or wordless is not an option. As Edmund Burke says,"The usually thing compulsory for a delight of immorality is for great group to do nothing."
It might be removed that a former IGP conspired with a Attorney-General (A-G), as well as a MACC to destroy Dato' Ramli's reputation as well as career. But they failed as Dato Ramli was clear by a courts upon all charges.
I did not tell Ramli that we would not attend. we just thanked him for a call in . we after detected that a stream IGP, Tan Sri Ismail Omar, gave him a grand send off (Hafiz Yatim's essay below) in a most appropriate traditions of a PDRM.
I was told that he was since a ensure of respect salute as well as was sent off in a Police rite Land Rover accompanied by PDRM bagpiper's impetus past with a IGP himself walking behind a Land Rover! as well as all a PDRM Directors as well as Police Chiefs in tow. Apparently it was a really romantic send off. we am certain Dato' Ramli was really changed by this gesticulate of confession by a Force, belated as that might be.
If we had previously thought that Dato' Ramli Yusuf had sole out, we contingency to apologize since a former CCID Director did not chop his difference in his farewell debate . It was a tough hitting debate where he singled out a "devious behavior" of a former IGP as well as a stream A-G.
Let us hope that today's rite send off has brought about a great end to a humiliation as well as indignities Dato Ramli Yusuf suffered for half a decade. The Force that had obviously deserted him (and his 5 officers too) when he indispensable its support has right away voiced its bewail openly. That should be great sufficient during least for a time being. Tan Sri Ismail Omar can right away focus upon rebuilding PDRM's image as well as morale.
As for Dato Ramli Yusuf, we instruct him all a most appropriate in his retirement. we am hopeful, however, that during a appropriate time, he will not demur to initiate authorised proceedings opposite both a former IGP Musa Hassan as well as a obligatory A-G Abdul Gani Patail.Din Merican
Ramli Yusuf hits out during former IGP Musa Hassan as well as A-G Gani Patail
by Hafiz Yatim@www.malaysiakini.com
After being ashamed as well as facing 5 trumped-up charges of non-disclosure of his assets, from that he was after acquitted, former Commercial Crime Investigation Department (CCID) Director Dato' Ramli Yusuff was honoured with an central early retirement rite by Inspector-General of Police (IGP) Tan Sri Ismail Omar in Bukit Aman, Kuala Lumpur today.
Ramli, in his farewell speech, lashed out during a benefaction Attorney-General (A-G), Abdul Gani Patail as well as former IGP Musa Hassan.
He pronounced he never illusory a force would tumble for a divergent poise of a prior IGP as well as a stream AG.
"It took over 5 years for my cases to be ruled upon by a probity complement as well as my sum ignorance to be confirmed Not usually were a Press as well as A-G's Office ready to make use of any means compulsory to try as well as get a guilty outcome opposite me, but also for a first time in history, a serving IGP testified opposite a single of his own Directors when he gave justification contradicting multiform of his alternative officers including those of a rank of director. Ultimately, a judge rebuked that IGP for his dubious witness testimony," he said.
Ramli, who had been a career Police Officer for 38 years, was referring to what is right away well known as Copgate.
Not usually was Ramli charged, his lawyer Rosli Dahlan as well as 6 youth officers investigating Copgate were also charged. Rosli as well as a 6 youth officers were also clear but their defence being called.
"Even when a 6 youth officer, my friend as well as we were all clear but a defence being called, that IGP (Musa) did not see fit to recognise my ignorance in any manner nor supposing any difference of support for a single of his own tip officers after being totally deemed innocent by a probity system. The A-G abused his dominant position to perpetuate a miseries as well as sq! uandered additional taxpayers resources to appeal all of a innocent verdicts. These verdicts have all been upheld by a higher courts," pronounced Ramli.
Some of a former officers benefaction in a eventuality enclosed former Selangor Police Chief Dell Akbar Khan, benefaction Selangor Police Chief Tun Hisan Tun Hamzah, Johor Police Chief Mohd Mokhtar Mohd Shariff, Bukit Aman Deputy CID Chief Hadi Ho Abdullah, Ramli's mother Anita Haron, a Sessions Court judge, as well as former Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission Adviser Robert Phang.
IGP Ismail bringing winds of change
Ramli serve credited Ismail with bringing a winds of change when he agreed to say a 6 youth officers in their rightful place in a Force.
Some of a officers had to drive taxis to make ends meet when they were suspended."Today we see a force closing ranks in esprit de corps, feeling togetherness, restoring a suggestion of camaraderie as well as multitude inside of a force. This can usually outrider a improved future for a force. That is how a force should function. In return, it is a obligatory duty of a care inside of a force to protect its officers. The prior care rejected that principal element as well as almost broken a fabric that makes a force what it is. The prior care acted in his own interest," he said.
Striking back during Musa, Ramli called upon members of a Force as well as retirees to convene behind Ismail.
"! We conti ngency all support him (Ismail) while retirees contingency not undermine him like what is being done by a former IGP, casting doubt upon Police statistics upon crime.That is dishonourable. Thus a force contingency be heedful of a enemies from within," he said, in obvious reference to Musa's rebuke of Ismail.
Ramli also credited his mother with adhering by him by adversities when he was charged. He described a highlight faced by Anita as unimaginable, seeing him being paraded before a probity corridors for public gibe as well as ridicule.
"She was not supposed to be with an indicted since she is a judge. As a result she faced her own hurdles as she was eliminated to Ipoh since she was beside me when we was charged," he said.
Ramli also recognized that a universe as well as Malaysia is rapidly changing as well as a police had to also change in tandem to sojourn applicable as well as this is probably something with that a force has nonetheless to come to grips.
Saying he is willing to help a force adapt to a global challenges, a former tip patrolman who has set up his own in isolation practise in 2009 pronounced right away police would be compulsory to correlate some-more with society, as well as urge its precision as well as enforcing of a law.
In a event, he vowed to make use of his RM753,000 gratuity from his early retirement to build a mosque for his kampung in Kampung Bunut Susu in Pasir Mas, where a wakaf land has been identified.
Ramli was since a central early retirement rite after he had been privileged of all a charges. He had first been charged in 2007, months before he was due to retire.
During a event, he as well as Anita were since a send-off by ro! ving upo n a special vehicle, accompanied by a police bagpipes playing 'Auld Lang Syne' as officers lined a highway heading out of Bukit Aman, to salute him as he exited to his central retirement.
Ismail also handed Ramli his Police early retirement label as well as mementos during a event.
Read More @ Source
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Is Malaysia an Islamic or a secular state?
November 16, 2012
If Malaysia is not a physical state as well as Dr. Malik Munip is uncertain if it is an Islamic state, it contingency afterwards be a confused state.Din Merican
Is Malaysia an Islamic or a physical state?
By Dr. Malik Munip@www.nst.com.my
The plead upon a inlet of Malaysia's identitywhether it is a physical or an Islamic stateis mired in confusion. The difficulty firstly is of a semantic naturea miss of clarity upon what defines a physical or an Islamic state. The second difficulty is about a border of any entity's authoritybe it former Premiers, The Alliance Memorandum or a Reid Commissionin deciding a debate. This article will plead a second difficulty first.
Secular or Islamic State: Premier vs. Premier
Though Malaysian Prime Ministers have been vested with a total battery of senior manager authority, nonetheless, they do not have a power to settle a temperament of a country merely by creation an announcement possibly way. Indeed, if we think about it, even an individual's temperament cannot be determined by a pronouncementa chairman doesn't become a Muslim, a Christian, an apostate or any temperament along a 'faith- atheist' spectrum simply due to a declaration. To have meaning as well as force, a stipulation contingency correspond with a individual's belief as well as practice. So if by itself a stipulation cannot settle a eremite temperament of an individual, can it settle a temperament of a state?
Nonetheless, most people charge Malaysia temperament as possibly Islamic or Secular, by citing a positions of prior Prime Ministers upon a subject. Hence to seaside up their claim, a proponents of a physical state wil! l mostly pull upon a statements of Tunku Abdul Rahman as well as Tun Hussien Onn.
In this courtesy an mostly cited matter (but not a usually example) used to paint a in front of of a former Premiers would be from a February 1983 Star inform where a Tunku pronounced "The country has a multi-racial race with assorted beliefs. Malaysia contingency continue as a physical State with Islam as a central religion".
Another emanate additionally reported Tun Hussein await for a Bapa Kemerdekaan, "The nation can still be functional as a physical state with Islam as a central religion."
Unsurprisingly those which argue which Malaysia is already an Islamic State wouldn't cite a initial as well as third Premiers. Instead they would quote Tun Mahathir's following matter in Sep 2001 to await their position: "UMNO wishes to state obviously which Malaysia is an Islamic nation. This is based upon a perspective of ulamaks who had clarified what constituted as Islamic country. " .
But with all due respects, there have been boundary in last a inlet of a country's temperament by simple reference to a Prime Ministerial declaration. After all, if Malaysia already possesses most of a facilities which conclude a physical state, afterwards her physical inlet doesn't change usually since a Prime Minister says otherwise. And clamp versaif Malaysia has most attributes of an Islamic state, or a underline which disqualifies her from being a physical state, afterwards it won't be a physical State in any case of how most prior as well as destiny Prime Ministers states to a contrary.
So yet they have been Prime Ministers, nonetheless, their statements, in as well as by themselves do not automatically settle a inlet of Malaysia's identity. At best their statements would be a description of Malaysia's pre-existing identity. And similar to most descri! ptions, it would be valid usually in so distant it is accurate.
The Alliance Memoranda vs. The Reid Commission
Of course, in articulating their positions, participants in a plead don't limit themselves to Prime Ministerial declarationsreferences to authorised authorities as well as authorised papers will additionally be partial of a controversial arsenal. In this courtesy nothing comes with aloft prestige than a Federal Constitution as well as a drafters, a Reid Commission. So with apply oneself to either Malaysia is an Islamic or a physical state, let's sink our teeth in to what a Federal Constitution as well as a Reid Commission have to say upon a matter.
In a Federal Constitution, both terms, Islamic State or Secular State does not appear. Nonetheless, Article 3 of a Federal Constitution states which Islam is a sacrament of a Federation. This sustenance has mostly been cited to await a explain which Malaysia is an Islamic State or during least not a physical one.
Yet, most who explain to have read a Reid Report find this justification unconvincing; they maintain which a Commission stated which any sustenance in a due Constitution upon condition which for Islam as a state sacrament will not nullify a in front of of a Federation as a physical state.
Strictly speaking, this portrayal of a Reid Commission's in front of is incorrect. In apply oneself to Islam being done a state religion, a Commission did not commit itself to which position. As historian Joseph Fernando wrote in his book 'The Making of a Malayan Constitution': "In apply oneself of religion, a Commission motionless not to have any sustenance relating to an central sacrament for a Federation yet a Alliance had due which Islam should be done a central religion".
In actuality it was a Alliance as well as not a Reid Commission which longed for a stipulation for Islam to be done a State Religion. And similarly, it was a Alliance which done a explain which such a stipula! tion wou ld not negate a in front of of a federation as a physical state. What a Reid Commission did was to acknowledge (see divide 169 of a report) which a Alliance longed for to insert such a provision; they themselves were demure to commit to it (with a difference of a single member, Justice Hamid).
Be which as it may, even if was a Alliance as well as not a Reid Commission which done a explain which carrying a state sacrament would not negate Malaya's standing as a physical state, nonetheless, shouldn't such a explain infer over doubt, which Malaysia is a physical State? After all, a Alliance played a consequential role in a constitution-making processbefore, during as well as after a Reid Commission's drafting. Additionally, they were a primary characters concerned in securing Independence; hence, if a Founding Fathers explain which a country is a physical State, afterwards it contingency be binding right? Not quite.
Firstly, nothing of them were recognized authorities upon a inter-related emanate of secular states as well as secularism, or a relationship to sacrament as well as Islamic States.
It should be noted which a emanate of an Islamic State has theological dimensions, yet nothing of them were theologians. And upon a emanate of a physical State, a complaint was which they never defined scrupulously what a physical state is; they usually claimed which carrying Islam as a sacrament of a Federation doesn't annul a standing as a physical state. Within a context of such statements, their source of a physical state seems to be a source by negationconceiving it by what it is not, rather than what it is. Such a source is not convincing.
In short, since a Alliance were not experts upon a emanate of Secular States, secularism or a relationship to Islam as well as not exact in conveying what they mean! t, does it have sense for us to elevate their explain (that carrying a state sacrament doesn't negate Malaya as a Secular State) as being a last management upon a matter?
Indeed according to a Joseph Fernando, there is justification which in private, even a Reid Commission were not remonstrate by a Alliance claimto them, it was a contradiction. And for those who have some bearing to a novel upon physical states as well as secularism, this shouldn't be surprising. Why? Because a Alliance's in front of usually doesn't correspond with a supposed bargain of what constitutes a physical state. And which is a point: if a matter or description doesn't match up with a reality afterwards in any case of a social station of a entity creation a statement, it cannot be authoritative.
So in last either Malaysia is a physical state or otherwise, instead of citing what former Premiers or a Reid Commission or a Alliance Memoranda says upon a matter, it would be some-more pertinent to ask: What defines a physical state? And does a matter of a Alliance Memoranda as well as those which relate it, tally with such a definition?
What is a Secular State? The Acid Test
The novel upon a theme of physical states as well as secularism is vast; as such there exist assorted interpretations. Nonetheless, there is a ubiquitous consensus which a substructure of a physical state is a element which state as well as sacrament contingency be separate. Consequently, a physical state will have, between others, a following characteristics: a state contingency be neutral towards religion; a state cannot give sacrament a payoff in front of in a open arena; a state's coercive powers as well as resources cannot be utilized in a use of any religion; a State should not payoff a sacrament or a adherents over another; a state should not payoff sacrament over irreligion; a state should not assent sacrament to be a order of open office; as well as a state should not interfere with a affairs of sacrame! nt as we ll as vice- versa.
Now by carrying Article 3 of a Federal Constitution, obviously Malaysia is not neutral towards religion. It gives Islam a privileged standing over alternative religions. Nonetheless, if Article 3 was a usually Islamic underline in a Constitution, maybe a explain by a Alliance which carrying a State Religion doesn't indicate a non-secular state can still be defended. But let's have a peek during alternative Articles of a Federal Constitution.
Through Article 11(4), companion work amongst Muslims can be controlled as well as restricted. Yet there have been no laws restricting companion work to adherents of alternative faiths. Then there's Article 12(2). This article has distant reaching consequences; it empowers a Federation as well as a states to settle or maintain Islamic institutions or provide assistance in which process. It additionally sanctions them to do same with regards to upon condition which direction in a sacrament of Islam. In pursuant of those purposes, it additionally authorises a use of open funds.
Both a upon top of Articles violate a beliefs of a physical state upon multiple scores. And these dual Articles have been not a usually one; there exist alternative Articles which do a same. For instance, Malays have been entitled to wear a cloak of Article 153, though professing Islam is a order of being Malay underneath a Federal Constitution. But let's expel our view over a Federal Constitution to a State Constitutions whereby a Islamic facilities have been even some-more pronounced.
Many State Constitutions require a State Secretary to be a chairman who professes Islam. In those States a default authorised order for a in front of of a Menteri Besar is additionally a chairman who professes Islam. And a state sacrament ! of most of a States which have up a Federation is Islam. In these States, not usually is neutrality towards Islam not practice, though unlike a federal in front of of Prime Minister, sacrament is done a order of a open offices of a Menteri Besar as well as State Secretary. And over a formal make up of a constitution, there have been alternative characteristics which these states have which have been during contingency with a essence of a physical state. With a name similar to Terengganu Darul Iman for example, is it realistic to design otherwise? And does Kelantan underneath Nik Aziz seem similar to a physical state to you? But it is not a scope of this article to elaborate.
Conclusion
So to reproduce a question: Is Malaysia a physical state? Well, by a characteristics which conclude a physical state afterwards Malaysia by clarification is not a physical state; it violates a element attributes of a physical state upon multiple fronts. Breaches to a tenants of a physical state have been not a exception; it is almost a rule. In Malaysia, sacrament is not distant from a state though entrenched, empowered, enforced, voiced as well as elevated.
Hence, does this meant Malaysia is an Islamic State? My answer is: we don't know; we have no idea what a universally supposed Islamic state in a contemporary universe looks like. But it does meant Malaysia disqualifies from being a physical state.
Dr Malik Munip taught story during University of Malaya for dual decades, as well as was additionally a former Member of Parliament for Muar.
Read More @ Source
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Is Malaysia an Islamic or secular state?
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Unholy chatter unnerves PKR leader
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Three cops charged with 'gang rape'
Session Court decider Nabishah Ibrahim read out the charge underneath Section 376 of the Penal Code for rape as well as Section 377(c) for forced assumed sex during the military hire in Prai upon Nov 9.
The trio, Sin Mat Lazim, 33, Syahiran Ramli, 21, as well as Remy Anak Pana, 21, whose seven-day remand finished today, claimed trial.
If found guilty, the contingent face the maximum twenty years' jail term as well as whipping.
Since 8am, the large organisation of reporters had been staking out the justice building, available the arrival of the suspects.
They finally came during 2.15pm, escorted by 3 military officers, with multiform others upon stand-by.
They were in their orange phony lock-up attire, heads covered with their own shirts.
Upon saying the trio, the organisation of cameramen rushed to the scene.
Penang Indonesian consulate behaving director-general Sofiana Mufidah was present in cour! t.
The trio, all constables, have been suspended from duties.
The situation allegedly happened during about 7am during the military hire in Prai upon Nov 9 after the contin! gent app rehended the 25-year-old victim for purportedly not being means to furnish her passport.
She is currently looking sanctuary during the Indonesian Consulate in Penang, available her return home as well as is pronounced to be in "good health".
State military chief Abdul Rahim Hanafi has pronounced investigators have available statements from 10 witnesses in relation to the purported offence.
Deputy open prosecutors Suhaimi Ibrahim as well as Nurashikin Mokhtar have been prosecuting, whilst lawyer Rosli Ismail is holding the watching brief.
[More to follow]
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |