Combo picture of this year's National Day trademark (bottom, which has given been scrapped after being heavily criticised) versus a logos of prior National Days.
The ultimate controversy, entrance just days after a open outcry forced Putrajaya to axe a badly-designed 55th National Day trademark in foster of a 1 Malaysia logo, could see some-more red cheeks for supervision officials as well as could further strain tactful ties with a Southeast Asian giant.
Malaysia's chattering category has been vicious over a "Janji Ditepati" lyrics, penned by Information, Communications as well as Culture Minister Datuk Seri Rais Yatim though 4 days ago, they strong their attacks upon renouned video-sharing site YouTube, as well as alternative amicable networking sites similar to Facebook after a blogger who avowed to be a Christian forked out which a song's tune was strikingly identical to an Indonesian gospel strain titled "Serukan Namanya" (Call out His name).
"Lagu tema KEMERDEKAAN MALAYSIA ke 55 kedengaran seperti LAGU Pujian di GEREJA (Malaysia's 55th National Day thesis strain sounds similar to a church praise song)," pronounced a unknown blogger's Jul thirty entry.
"Hal ini lagi mengejutkan sekiranya lagu tema kebangsaan di ambil dari lagu rohani org Kristen Mungkin kementerian tidak tau tapi seharusnya pencipta lagu ni tdk berbuat demikian (menciplak) sebab did ditugaskan untk membuat lagu tema kemerdekaan. [This make a difference is all a some-more intolerable if a inhabitant thesis stra! in is ta ken from a Christians' spiritual strain Perhaps a method is unknowingly though a songwriter should not do so (plagiarise) given he was tasked with creating a inhabitant theme]," a blogger said.
The unnamed blogger urged a method to direct a refund from a songwriter as well as to reinstate a song, which has been panned for a lyrics, with another.
Copies of a posting as well as video links to both "Janji Ditepati" as well as a some-more aged to "Serukan Namanya" have given left viral as well as were steady upon multiform blogs as well as online community fora such as Miricommunity.net, an Internet bulletin board popularly visited by Malaysians who accost from Sarawak.
"Amen, Yesuslah Raja!! Tapi contemptible ya, Rais Yatim dengan lagu 'Janji Ditepati'nya sama character dengan lagu ni (Amen Jesus is King!! But sorry, Rais Yatim with his 'Janji Ditepati' has a same character as this song)," pronounced a YouTube commentor under a moniker amoker27 in one of a video clips featuring a Indonesian songherethat has seen over 100,000 views given being uploaded upon September 5, 2008.
The song, by Christian band True Worshippers led by Sidney Mohede as well as whose members embody a regionally renouned artist Ruth Sahanaya, was expelled in their 2008 album "All Things New".
"Now i really hatred a method given transcribe this strain as well as make it domestic in malaysia. really contrition of my own country given of a idiot minister. contemptible indonesia!!" pronounced another YouTube commenter under a name vandridel.
The reparation to Indonesia was in anxiety to dissapoint Indonesians who pounded Malaysia's missions in a archipelago, hurling eggs, stones as well as pieces of wood injuring personnel as well as deleterious property as not long ago as June, claiming informative burglary after Rais had voiced a move to supplement North Sumatra's Tortor dance as well as a Gordang Sambilan dru! ms to a a birthright list.
The dual beside countries have been well known to have a story of political, economic, as well as informative friction.
But "Janji Ditepati's" tune was purportedly created by a organisation of people customarily identified as Aye, Jasnie, Arman E six.
A YouTube posting of a video clipherehas drawn over 255,000 views given it was uploaded upon Jul twenty-seven with over 30,600 dislikes compared to customarily 415 likes as of this morning.
Rais had additionally concurred a brickbats when he took to Twitter dual days ago as well as invited a open to share their views upon a strain he wrote.
"Apa pandangan sdr tntg lagu janji d tepati? Di utube dah cecah 140k lebih. Tapi yg 'ibu jari k bawah' ada juga (What have been your views upon a Janji Ditepati song? On YouTube, there have been some-more than 140,000 views. But there have been those who have additionally given it a 'thumbs-down'," a apportion pronounced upon his account @DrRaisYatim.
Sev eral singers, songwriters as well as composers contacted byThe Malaysian Insiderhave additionally remarkable a distinguished similarities in in between a "Janji Ditepati" tune as well as a gospel strain though stopped short of labelling it plagiarism.
"Similarities in tune customarily would bring up a emanate of plagiarism," pronounced strain educator Tay Cher Siang, who is additionally strain director for The Venue, a live strain space during renouned city mall Pavilion.
He concluded which there were most similarities in in between a dual melodies though pronounced which a strain scale is limited as it contains customarily 12 notes. He combined which most cocktail strain compositions frequently feature 7 notes.
"No make a difference how most I hated a total 'Janji Ditepati' fiasco, to be fair, I have an unit of disbelief for this emanate of plagiarism," he said.
He was loathe to code it! an outr ight low-pitched theft, observant he had no believe if a composers of "Janji Ditepati" were aware of a similarities w! ith "S erukan Namanya" as well as had been shabby by a strain as well as sought accede to use a tune or had upon purpose reproduced it without attributing a inspiration.
Folk thespian as well as songwriter Meor Yusof Aziddin, 45, echoed Tay's view, observant a emanate of plagiarising low-pitched melodies was very subjective. He forked out which cocktail melodies have regulating a same regulation given a Beatles' epoch in a 1960s as well as 1970s.
He remarkable which a inhabitant anthem, "Negaraku", has a same tune as an Indonesian song, "Terang Boelan", as well as which can be traced behind to an 18th-century song, "La Rosalie", by French composer Pierre-Jean de Beranger.
Another independent singer-songwriter-composer, who declined to be named, however, was intrigued by a similarities in in between a choice National Day tune as well as gospel music.
"That there is substantive likeness in in between an Indonesian Christian gospel strain as well as a brand new Malaysian Merdeka day strain is interesting, do not you think?" he asked.
The statute Barisan Nasional (BN) coalition had chosen "Janji Ditepati as a thesis for this year's National Day celebrations, a move which has drawn heated criticism from a antithesis as well as Malaysians.
The antithesis Pakatan Rakyat (PR) leaders have indicted a BN supervision of hijacking National Day celebrations for a own domestic campaign.
They additionally indicted BN of regulating a thesis to abuse supervision machinery for domestic campaigning purposes.
Last Friday, Rais had defended upon Twitter a National Day celebrations theme, indicating out which "everything can look bad if a mind is closed".
"Malaysia has indeed arrived as an achieving nation after 55 years of independence. Why can't we contend janji ditepati?" he pronounced in response to g! rowing c riticisms against a thesis for mirroring BN's domestic campaign thesis ahead of a subsequent ubiquitous election expected soon.
Read More @ Source More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Courtesy of Bonology.com Politically Incorrect Buzz & Buzz
No comments:
Post a Comment