Why Im not fond of Rafizis plan
The thought of abolishing the PTPTN seems noble, though the execution doesn't appear to supplement up.
COMMENT
Yes, we am talking about the dissolvement of PTPTN as good as the giveaway preparation devise which PKR strategies executive Razifi Ramli talked about during the brand new discuss with Umno Youth chief Khairy Jamaluddin.
Now the reason given we call it Rafizi's devise is given it seems which this total gig is the one-man show, saying how wordless the alternative parties have been when it comes to this gargantuan task.
With DAP some-more capitalistic than socialistic these days as good as PAS which seems to be some-more interested in muzakarah some-more than anything elese, it seems like, or during slightest the perception is which Rafizi had to came out with the last-minute devise to be somewhat convincing to await the statement done by his boss, the de facto personality of PKR who some-more often than not regurgitates random promises in the feeling of well-being of the domestic ceramah.
Now this arrogance is not done though basement saying how this devise was never referred to in the Buku Jingga as Khairy forked out. Nonetheless we commend Rafizi for during slightest trying to present the sort of resource rsther than than simply promising the moon as good as stars as his trainer often did.
Now Rafizi argued the approach things have been starting as good as looking during the actuality by which the volume of debt the student had to lift upon graduation as good as saying how this series was growing, there indispensable to be the revamp in the preparation funding mechanism.
He argued how alternative countries were confronting monetary meltdowns due to the weight of debt carried by their citizens as good as the incapacity for them to use these loans, saying how the preparation debt was flourishing day by day there should come the time when the debt burden was so vast the marketplace would default as the result formulating the meltdown, saying which maybe in the nearby destiny we competence confront something identical to the subprime mortgage predicament which the US faced.
To equivocate this, it seems, was to giveaway the stream generation from the immorality clutches of loans. The supervision or in this box the Pakatan Rakyat supervision would introduce giveaway education, annul all of the stream as good as past debts as good as yield subsidies to the private preparation sector as the result ensuring which students would not have the poignant burden of debt once they graduated. After all, according to them, giveaway preparation was the right of any Malaysian.
It seems noble but
It seems noble though someway it only don't appear to fit. Let me put this in another perspective. Let's only contend the immature man would identical to to acquire the automobile so which he could commute around town. To do this he would have to take the loan with the bank as good as pay off it in installments of 7 years.
But 7 years is the prolonged time as good as most things could occur in 7 years, fearing which this immature man competence not be able to use this loan in the destiny as good as not wanting for him to lift such the vast debt early in his life, it would be best if he could get the automobile for free, though as we know, zero is giveaway as good as someone would have to bear the price of shopping this automobile in income as good as that's customarily the parents. Unless the relatives have been dirty abounding people, do we consider it's correct for them to outlay their hold up assets this way? Woul! dn't whi ch impact the provision of the total family?
In this case, the supervision is the relatives as good as the assets or the source of the income would be the supervision coffers which would directly impact the economy. So when we outlay the vast volume of income to equivocate the predicament which competence occur in the future, maybe rsther than than solving it, all we have been we do was to safeguard the monetary predicament right away saying how we callously outlay the vast volume of your bill to pay the vast debt in one go.
Even worse than the analogy we only gave, during slightest in the box of shopping the automobile it is the one time purchase, upon the alternative palm this giveaway preparation as good as large subsidies is an ongoing thing as good as saying how our race is flourishing as good as the goods of inflation, the price which the supervision indispensable to bear would enlarge annually as good as wouldn't this trigger an even bigger monetary meltdown?
Subsidising private education
Then of march we have the devise to subsidise private institution fees so which it would compare those in the public institutions. Now for the moment put yourselves in the boots of the owner of the private institution of aloft learning. Say you're the owner of the private college, saying during how your primary goal was to make distinction (after all this is the commercial operation venture) as good as right away saying which the supervision was subsidising most of your fees creation it some-more affordable to the masses, wouldn't it be logical to enlarge the volume of student intakes any semester?
After all it's affordable as good as given the supervision was bearing most of the cost, wouldn't it be good to have some-more intakes which would directly enlarge my profit. we would find creative ways to introduce brand new courses as good as faculties as good as would even lobby the thought which by we do so we am con! tributin g to the nation by giving opportunities to some-more Malaysians to tertiary education.
What does this mean then? Well to put it plainly, the supervision would afterwards have to enlarge the volume of income spent upon subsidising the attention annually as the result enlarge in price as time goes by, marketplace mechanisms as good as improvement aren't in place given the supervision had intervened in this way.
Then of march there's the box of consequence as good as productivity, the stream resource ensures which students who work hard, those who do good would be rewarded by carrying their loans incited in to scholarships. Now if everybody was promised as good as assured of the giveaway education, where is the motivation to get the initial category honours upon graduation, what's the indicate of investigate tough in propagandize when any alternative average bloke was ensured of the giveaway ride?
Take for e.g. this, who would wish to take the JPA medical grant as good as be connected to work for the supervision for 8 years when we get giveaway preparation which was identical to the grant as good as though carrying to be connected to anyone. You competence as good investigate during the local university, get which medical grade as good as afterwards quit to the developing country, removing aloft pay in the aloft currency. And the only approach for us to fill in the necessity is to suggest aloft salaries to not only compare the international marketplace demand though to also hedge the disproportion in currency value.
Rafizi forked out which as an accountant he had distributed all this as good as which the numbers which he came to interpretation Malaysia could undertake such the project. However, we find which the numbers appear to be some-more convenient rsther than than exact, especially given most of the numbers were based upon assumptions as good as projections.
In most cases, the necessity of funds or the retort which he gave were alo! ng the l ines of "When we take over, we would get absolved of crime as the result the supervision would save gazillion of dollars as the result we could afford all this."
The problem was which when it comes to politicians, difference as good as promises aren't really which solid, saying during how his de facto personality seemed to dont consider about all about Sept sixteen as good as the throngs of promises which went down the drain. Action speaks louder than difference as good as given carrying control over the state supervision surely we could infer to the rakyat your worthiness.
Selangor should be able to suggest giveaway preparation via Unisel the university controlled by the state supervision in conditions of policies, bill as good as even the management. If we keep throwing excuses as good as blaming the prior supervision for your incapacity to infer your point, afterwards we could disagree which we competence do the same thing when we take over the sovereign government, which we would afterwards throw this total grandiose devise of yours as good as simply put the censure upon BN.
Action carries the lot of weight as good as as Khairy forked out, if we can't even keep your guarantee of providing giveaway kindergarten preparation when receiving over Selangor, what makes we consider people have been starting to buy your promises this time around.
Zaidel Baharuddin is Mr Right, Mr Right Wing which is, electronics operative by day writer by night, Frank Sinatra fanboy all day long, catch me during WirawanWeb.com,lipassepi.blogspot.comor follow me upon twitter via @Sinatra_Z. He is the FMT columnist. Read More @ Source More
Barisan Nasional (BN) |
Pakatan Rakyat (PR) |
Sociopolitics Plus |
No comments:
Post a Comment