Foreword by CPI A organisation of endangered relatives have been creation a illustration to Suhakam with courtesy to many longstanding complaints about Moral Studies taught in upper delegate school.
For many years now, a hearing format of this theme has been so firm which students have been forced to strictly memorize 36 'values' as well as definitions. They have been afterwards mandatory to regurgitate word for word what they've memorized when sitting a SPM paper.
Such a process of testing probity is many suitable matched to precision parrots as well as appears to be written by monkeys.Who have been these monkeys which have been instrumental in designing a hearing as well as how have they been authorised to get divided with their gorilla commercial operation for so long?
Any girl who has been prepared to think critically might well ask, since 36 values, as well as since not 35 or 37? Who defines these 'values'? Why must definitions drafted by a little textbook writers be so formidable which not a word is to be changed? Even a 10 Commandments handed down by God from atop Mount Sinai concede more flexibility in their wording.
Poor SPM formula in Moral Studies have penalized non-Muslim students who otherwise had scored straight As or A+ in their alternative subjects.
In comparison, Muslim students who have been exempted from Moral Studies but instead take a Islamic Studies writings do not have to risk their SPM balance sheet being pulled down due to below-par opening in this a singular theme alone.
Even inside of a inhabitant hearing system, there exists a two-tier streaming formed upon sacrament which has prompted non-Muslim relatives to cry foul.
While there is zero disgusting to having Moral Studies in a syllabus, it should yet be private from a SPM slate.
The! non-Mus lim relatives have been representing to Suhakam which their children's preparation right to a satisfactory hearing assessment is being compromised by this mandatory paper which discriminates upon a basement of religion.
Beyond this petition, there have been pass questions as well as concerns which need to be acted as well as answered. How can Malay/Muslim-oriented open systems run by Malay elites be finished to be pure as well as underneath obligation so which they do not discriminate or reprove non-Malays as well as non-Muslims?
Why have been such policies of transparent discrimination as well as influence against certain segments of Malaysians sustaining as well as how do you safeguard which they do not recur?
This entire episode needs to be opened up for full open contention as well as scrutiny. It might be a tip of a iceberg of a structural deformity inside of our open service which needs to be exposed, operated upon as well as excised.
The CPI team looks brazen to hearing more from a open upon this as well as identical unconscionable policies generally inspiring our young.
Moral Studies SPM formula Demoralising!
My daughter was a tyro of SMK Tarcisian Convent, Ipoh who obtainedher SPM formula upon Mar 22, 2012.
She, together with eight of her friends, managed to get 8A+ for all subjects they tookexcept for Moral Studies. you hold for a first time in a history of a pronounced school none of its 120-odd students got A+ for a subject.
This outcome might seem zero out of a typical except which in thestandardized SPM trials - which is a hearing paper as well as answer intrigue set by a respective state preparation dialect 26 of a Fifth Formersobtained A+ for Moral Studies. Another 40 or so students obtained an A.
How is it afterwards which not a singular tyro obtained an A+ for Moral Studies in theactual SPM examination?The predicament of t! hese stu dents was at length highlighted in a print media StarMetro,Tamil NesanandMakkal Osaion Mar 23,Nanban(March 25) as well as a electronic mediaMalaysiakiniandPerakview.
A sum of 39 students have appealed to a Examination Board to have their hearing formula re-checked with payment of RM50 as well as awaiting a outcome which might take up to 3 months from a date of a release of a SPM results. By a time a outcome is known a students would have mislaid their chance to request for JPA as well as countless alternative scholarships as well as entrance into universities/colleges of their choice since of their incapacity to secure an A+ in Moral Studies.
Therefore, a lackadaisical perspective of board in receiving 3 months to revert with a outcome ensures it is an act in futility, as well as a right to re-check illusory.Also to my surprise, after receiving up a predicament of a students in SMK Tarcisian Convent, you detected which many relatives have been not wakeful which Moral Studies is a mandatory theme only for a nonMuslim students which is taken into comment in last a altogether opening of a tyro in SPM.
Also have been you wakeful which Moral Studies is a "closed paper" which means which past year writings have been not accessible in a market for students to have use of as references? Why should it be so? Muslim students do not take Moral Studies but instead Islamic studies.
Logically, Moral Studies as part of a curriculum should be taught with a perspective to inculcating good values, so which when a students step out into a genuine world they would know how to conduct themselves in a manner acceptable in a courteous society. Therefore dignified studies should hold upon simple counts needed for every day co-existence, such as mutual respect, responsibility, tolerance, tractability to law, etc.
These have been counts which a singular can even sense from life's experiences. In a gist, there should be zero technical or mind boggling about stud! ying dig nified as a subject.
Somehow "the educationist" entrusted with a sketch up of a synopsis suspicion fit to have a theme as technical as possible with so much acerbity which students have been forced to memorize 36 "values" as well as definitions word for word as well as to regurgitate them like a parrot in a examination.
Any departure from a words used will be penalized. It baffles me to find which my daughter's schools intent "experts" to teach a students a technique of responding dignified studies questions. As you have been wakeful probity is a many subjective matter since what is a accepted normal as well as customary of conduct or behaviourdiffer from society to society as well as epoch to era.
Therefore what ought to have been a simple theme has been finished so formidable by a people entrusted with scheming a synopsis as well as setting a hearing questions which a non-Muslim students who surpass in a sciences as well as arithmetic do not transport well in Moral Studies.
This raises a few questions.
Does it means which a tyro who gets 8A+ in all alternative subjects except Moral Studies have been deemed not implicitly excellent or lacking in morality?
Does it additionally meant which Moral Studies is a theme far more formidable to comprehend as well as answer than a sciences as well as mathematics?
These questions clearly indicate, to quote Shakespeare, "that there is something decaying in a state of our preparation (not Denmark)".
This has been starting upon for more than 10 years as well as year in year out you listen to rumblings from students as well as relatives how they or their children have mislaid out since of a failure to secure A+ (before this 1A) in Moral Studies. However no petrify movement has been instituted till to date put an finish to this mockery.
Therefore a relatives of this year's affected tyro from SMK TarcisianConvent, Ipoh together with a assistance o! f an NGO intend to have illustration to Suhakam which Moral Studies be utterly private from a synopsis or at slightest downgraded to a non-examination paper in schools.
We intend to lift it as tellurian rights issue inspiring a minority in this nation (only a non-Muslims) as a right to satisfactory preparation is for every adult as well as is enshrined in a constitution as well as no a singular should be authorised to adopt that.
Furthermore, it is not satisfactory which non-Muslim students should study Moral Studies whilst Muslim students take Islamic studies as well as a formula from these dual really different subjects determine a altogether opening of a tyro in a critical hearing like SPM. How can a singular review a worth of an apple to an orange?
Also you feel a time is suitable to lift this issue as a government is requesting feedback from all stakeholders with a perspective to reviewing a entire preparation complement which has left to a dogs.
Course of action:
If you have been a tyro (or a relatives upon behalf of a student) who sat a SPM outcome 2012 as well as feel victimized by a Moral Studies hearing result, greatfully let us have a following information, namely a student's name, which school, howdid a tyro transport in a alternative subjects which a tyro took as well as what did a tyro acquire for Moral Studies in a trial hearing as well as in a tangible SPM result.
Please brazen all report as well as comments to a following emailaddress, namelymorallyupright@hotmail.co.ukthat you can hoard support to have an in effect illustration as well as see which probity is done.
You can additionally find us upon Facebook underneath a organisation Morally Upright.
* The above e-mail was circulated by S.V. Namasoo, coordinator. - CPIAsia
Read More @ Source More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Courtesy of Bonology.com Politically Incorrect Buzz & Buzz
No comments:
Post a Comment