"Jail's no home for a truth."- Carandiru
COMMENTThree years is not a long time. Here in Malaysia, it's only a year reduced of how long a complement of administration can legitimately reason upon to energy prior to it needs to reason an choosing to get a endorsement of a choosing by casting votes open to sojourn in power.
Three years for 'causing hurt' to A Kugan is what an military officer of a Royal Malaysian Police (PDRM) received.
The law will never be known in this box or in a hundreds or perhaps even thousands of others who have unexpected died in military custody, newcomer apprehension camps, military shootouts as well as jails over a years. We will never know a anguish of family groups of those killed or who have died in control due to negligence.
We might share their sense of snub yet a snub is widely separated with a disdain for a systemic crime which permeates each turn of government.
Our snub in a little cases is also dependent upon a guilt of a parties involved. We have been unexcited to a fates of convicted inmates as well as a unsanitary (and most often criminally negligent) conditions they have been housed in when it is a responsibility of a state to administer their welfare.
Our parasitic relationship with 'foreigners', legal or otherwise, does not leave much room for consolation when it comes to their gratification whilst in control for whatever reasons.
And prior to anyone accuses me of conflating assorted issues of a penal as well as coercion systems, let me remind you which tothis! s ystem, everybody who died is guilty or during slightest which is a presumption.
And similar to most Malaysians of a sure cate! gory (an d perhaps since of my previous professions) my interactions with a PDRM has been positive for a most partial - supposed illegal rallies excluded - yet personal version has no place in a face of a historical as well as stream crime of a system.
The Kugan box similar to most flashpoints when it comes to a PDRM or any of a coercion branches of a state reveals simmering competition as well as category tensions which have been so often glossed over in this country.
This box in sold is perhaps a most reasoning example of a state's disdain for a rights of a citizens.
Unconvincing cover-up
I have good admiration for a family of Kugan (as I do all alternative family groups in similar predicaments) who began a long journey of creation it impossible for a state to cover up a misdeeds usually to strech a destination of an groundless cover-up.
Blame was assigned, a verdict recorded, a judgment meted out, yet Kugan's family will never know a law as well as neither will we.
Most people would be informed with thegruesome autopsy picturesof Kugan yet to me what is even some-more sinister was a attempted cover up.
If his family didn'tbarge into a mortuary, a law or a inkling of it would most probably been cremated or buried. The! family could not even suffer in peace withmourners being arrested during a funeral.
The lies or bungle of thefirst pathologist(which usually warranted a reprimand) seemed similar to an boring shrug from a state, as if a murder of Kugan did not even aver a worldly cover-up. And since of a promotion for some, Kugan will always sojourn a 'suspected oppulance car thief" who died in custody.
It's times similar to these Malaysians have been reminded of a necessity of antithesis domestic parties as well as non-governmental organisations with N Surendran (whose work together with a alternative lawyers has been exemplary), Hindraf as well as most others (at assorted times) righteously branch this 'criminal' box into a domestic one.
I would disagree (and I am sure there will be most who disagree with me) which here in Malaysia since a complement has been so compromised which any genocide in control is an complaint opposite a statute complement of administration as well as a underlying ideology.
With choosing fever using high, those sensitive to a aims of Pakatan Rakyat have been publically forgetful of a approach how a Pakatan administration will right a wrongs of a complement riddled with years of abuse.
This, of course, is cold joy to a family groups of those slain by a complement over a years. Indian, Orang Asli, Malay, Chinese, Indonesian, as well as Burmese, a l! ist goes on.
The circumstances they died in might not have perceived a open inspection which Kugan's genocide did yet a complement over a years has most deaths to comment for even yet a stream home minister can't even get a numbers (of a deaths in custody) right in a stream administration.
Reform of a military as well as penal systems is such a gargantuan task which it is formidable to contemplate. No doubt a top-to-bottom approach is indispensable yet a being is which any reforms would be square meal or during worse cosmetic.
Whatever changes done will fit time as well as circumstance, this to gorge a final of rakyat disillusioned by a military force they perceive as corrupt or racist, there to do a behest of their domestic masters as well as not to safeguard their interests.
Reforms need sustained effort
The being is which any serious reform of a military force or a penal complement will take a sustained effort by successive governments committed to a principle of reforming these most vital of open services. It will involve some-more than only reforming state organs yet reforming mindsets, a open as well as a military personnel.
It would mean which a military force as an establishment would be some-more than only any alternative convenient supervision physique there to employ people who would not be employable in alternative jobs.
Of course, a worry here is which these reforms have been only partial o! f a matriarch ny alternative desperately indispensable reforms which this country requires. Cases similar to Kugan or Aminulrasyid Amzah or Teoh Beng Hock remind a Malaysian open of a disregard a stream complement of administration feels towards ordinary citizens.
On a alternative hand, a deaths as well as torture which occur in prisons as well as supposed illegal newcomer apprehension camps which is met with hardly a raised eyebrow by a Malaysian open is justification of a detachment a open has towards these issues.
I'm skeptical of law as well as settlement commissions for reasons which have been beyond a range of this piece, yet I often consternation how a elect similar to this would fool around out in this context.
What would they reveal? Malaysians have been prone to swindling theories as well as who could blame us? A muzzled press as well as a constant shadow plays which have been a partial of a lives have been gainful to a sold mindset which sees tendrils of connectors where nothing exist.
How would you as a nation react to a banal immorality which confronts us in these proceedings? How would sure communities react when a law of racial profiling as standard operating procession is exposed to a harsh glisten of a truth?
Would you be astounded during a turn of cooperation between a assorted branches of a confidence services as well as where their loyalties distortion or would you be asocial sufficient to expect such sinister alliances?
How would you react when you discover which a perpetrators were immature or ignorant or both! who wer e only following orders (an invalid defence) or which psychological hearing suggested which confidence crew displayed levels of disorders which done them unsuitable to reason a positions they held?
How would you react to a obvious injustice or teaching which their precision exposed them to? And if there were cover-ups as well as convicted crew were paid to take a fall, how much were they paid?
Three years for 'causing hurt' to A Kugan is what an military officer of a Royal Malaysian Police (PDRM) received.
The law will never be known in this box or in a hundreds or perhaps even thousands of others who have unexpected died in military custody, newcomer apprehension camps, military shootouts as well as jails over a years. We will never know a anguish of family groups of those killed or who have died in control due to negligence.
We might share their sense of snub yet a snub is widely separated with a disdain for a systemic crime which permeates each turn of government.
Our snub in a little cases is also dependent upon a guilt of a parties involved. We have been unexcited to a fates of convicted inmates as well as a unsanitary (and most often criminally negligent) conditions they have been housed in when it is a responsibility of a state to administer their welfare.
Our parasitic relationship with 'foreigners', legal or otherwise, does not leave much room for consolation when it comes to their gratification whilst in control for whatever reasons.And prior to anyone accuses me of conflating assorted issues of a penal as well as coercion systems, let me remind you which tothis! s ystem, everybody who died is guilty or during slightest which is a presumption.
And similar to most Malaysians of a sure cate! gory (an d perhaps since of my previous professions) my interactions with a PDRM has been positive for a most partial - supposed illegal rallies excluded - yet personal version has no place in a face of a historical as well as stream crime of a system.
The Kugan box similar to most flashpoints when it comes to a PDRM or any of a coercion branches of a state reveals simmering competition as well as category tensions which have been so often glossed over in this country.
This box in sold is perhaps a most reasoning example of a state's disdain for a rights of a citizens.
Unconvincing cover-up
I have good admiration for a family of Kugan (as I do all alternative family groups in similar predicaments) who began a long journey of creation it impossible for a state to cover up a misdeeds usually to strech a destination of an groundless cover-up.
Blame was assigned, a verdict recorded, a judgment meted out, yet Kugan's family will never know a law as well as neither will we.
Most people would be informed with thegruesome autopsy picturesof Kugan yet to me what is even some-more sinister was a attempted cover up.
If his family didn'tbarge into a mortuary, a law or a inkling of it would most probably been cremated or buried. The! family could not even suffer in peace withmourners being arrested during a funeral.
The lies or bungle of thefirst pathologist(which usually warranted a reprimand) seemed similar to an boring shrug from a state, as if a murder of Kugan did not even aver a worldly cover-up. And since of a promotion for some, Kugan will always sojourn a 'suspected oppulance car thief" who died in custody.
It's times similar to these Malaysians have been reminded of a necessity of antithesis domestic parties as well as non-governmental organisations with N Surendran (whose work together with a alternative lawyers has been exemplary), Hindraf as well as most others (at assorted times) righteously branch this 'criminal' box into a domestic one.I would disagree (and I am sure there will be most who disagree with me) which here in Malaysia since a complement has been so compromised which any genocide in control is an complaint opposite a statute complement of administration as well as a underlying ideology.
With choosing fever using high, those sensitive to a aims of Pakatan Rakyat have been publically forgetful of a approach how a Pakatan administration will right a wrongs of a complement riddled with years of abuse.
This, of course, is cold joy to a family groups of those slain by a complement over a years. Indian, Orang Asli, Malay, Chinese, Indonesian, as well as Burmese, a l! ist goes on.
The circumstances they died in might not have perceived a open inspection which Kugan's genocide did yet a complement over a years has most deaths to comment for even yet a stream home minister can't even get a numbers (of a deaths in custody) right in a stream administration.
Reform of a military as well as penal systems is such a gargantuan task which it is formidable to contemplate. No doubt a top-to-bottom approach is indispensable yet a being is which any reforms would be square meal or during worse cosmetic.
Whatever changes done will fit time as well as circumstance, this to gorge a final of rakyat disillusioned by a military force they perceive as corrupt or racist, there to do a behest of their domestic masters as well as not to safeguard their interests.
Reforms need sustained effort
The being is which any serious reform of a military force or a penal complement will take a sustained effort by successive governments committed to a principle of reforming these most vital of open services. It will involve some-more than only reforming state organs yet reforming mindsets, a open as well as a military personnel.
It would mean which a military force as an establishment would be some-more than only any alternative convenient supervision physique there to employ people who would not be employable in alternative jobs.
Of course, a worry here is which these reforms have been only partial o! f a matriarch ny alternative desperately indispensable reforms which this country requires. Cases similar to Kugan or Aminulrasyid Amzah or Teoh Beng Hock remind a Malaysian open of a disregard a stream complement of administration feels towards ordinary citizens.On a alternative hand, a deaths as well as torture which occur in prisons as well as supposed illegal newcomer apprehension camps which is met with hardly a raised eyebrow by a Malaysian open is justification of a detachment a open has towards these issues.
I'm skeptical of law as well as settlement commissions for reasons which have been beyond a range of this piece, yet I often consternation how a elect similar to this would fool around out in this context.
What would they reveal? Malaysians have been prone to swindling theories as well as who could blame us? A muzzled press as well as a constant shadow plays which have been a partial of a lives have been gainful to a sold mindset which sees tendrils of connectors where nothing exist.
How would you as a nation react to a banal immorality which confronts us in these proceedings? How would sure communities react when a law of racial profiling as standard operating procession is exposed to a harsh glisten of a truth?
How would you react when you discover which a perpetrators were immature or ignorant or both! who wer e only following orders (an invalid defence) or which psychological hearing suggested which confidence crew displayed levels of disorders which done them unsuitable to reason a positions they held?How would you react to a obvious injustice or teaching which their precision exposed them to? And if there were cover-ups as well as convicted crew were paid to take a fall, how much were they paid?
Is a hold up of a citizen some-more profitable than a foreigner? Is a hold up of a Malay male worth some-more than an Indian or Chinese?
Perhaps a usually compensation which these family groups merit is financial ones. It's a poultice resolution during best as well as if it equates to which BN pays by losing a charge as well as by winning Pakatan pays in cash, so be it. Someone has to pay.
Perhaps a usually compensation which these family groups merit is financial ones. It's a poultice resolution during best as well as if it equates to which BN pays by losing a charge as well as by winning Pakatan pays in cash, so be it. Someone has to pay.
S THAYAPARAN is Commander (rtd) in a Royal Malaysian Navy.
Read More @ Source More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Courtesy of Bonology.com Politically Incorrect Buzz & Buzz
No comments:
Post a Comment