Cops may have broken law in rejecting Bersih venue notice

By Clara Chooi

Apr 26, 2012

Screenshot of territory 14 of a Act. Picture pleasantness of Lawnet

KUALA LUMPUR, Apr twenty-six The military might have disregarded provisions in a Peaceful Assembly Act 2011, which only came in to force upon Monday, by rejecting undisguised Bersih's presentation for this Saturday's sit-in during a ancestral Dataran Merdeka in a collateral city.

Putrajaya has authorized a sit-in though both Kuala Lumpur City Hall (DBKL) as well as a military have rejected a Apr twenty-eight rally, observant it posed a safety threat. The authorities have proposed Stadium Merdeka or alternative circuitously stadiums though a electoral remodel transformation is insisting upon Dataran Merdeka.

File print of barriers during Dataran Merdeka put up by City Hall after it evicted Occupy Dataran activists from a place upon Apr 24, 2012. Picture by Choo Choy May

According to territory 14 of a Act, a military contingency respond to Bersih's presentation inside of 5 days of receipt as well as following this, a public "shall" proceed. The brand new law does not specifically concede a military to reject a presentation though says they can impose conditions as well as restrictions upon a convene organisers, including upon counts pertaining to a convene venue, time, date as well as others.

The military can only make use of its powers to detain or sunder a convene if its organisers or participants violate these specific conditions, a Act says.

When this was forked out to Datuk Ambiga Sreenavasan. a Bersih co-chair concluded which a military might have disregarded a law when it rejected a complete eventuality undisg! uised up on Monday, a day a Act had come in to force.

"Yes, we agree... we do not think they have been specifically following a Act so they might have left opposite a law. However, they could still make use of alternative provisions to locate us," she toldThe Malaysian Insiderwhen contacted yesterday.

The former Bar Council authority additionally voiced guess in a remarkable speed with which a just-passed law had come in to force, only 5 days prior to Bersih's planned public this Saturday.

"To be fair, it should have come in to force much earlier. Why all of a remarkable it was rushed?" she asked.

Deputy Minister in a Prime Minister's Department Datuk V.K. Liew reliable withThe Malaysian Insideryesterday which a Act, often referred to as PAA2011, officially come in to force upon Monday.

It was upheld by both Houses of Parliament last December, postulated royal recognition upon Jan 30 as well as gazetted in to law upon Feb 9.

But, pronounced Liew, a "designated places of assembly" underneath a Act have nonetheless to be specified by a ministry as well as gazetted.

This, he said, means which nonetheless Dataran Merdeka is not nonetheless deliberate as a venue which is not a gazetted "designated place of assembly", any celebration intending to organise a entertainment during a location contingency request for permission from a City Hall.

"It is underneath DBKL's reach as well as jurisdiction. As a owner, DBKL will have to decide. It is only similar to it is my house, we will confirm if we can make use of my compound.

"We have to be reasonable as well as respect a preference of a owner.

"It is therefore a right of a owners to concede or exclude any one from regulating a property," he told The Malaysian Insider in a text message.

According to a PAA2011, military permits are no longer required to hold an public though organisers contingency contenti! on a pre sentation to a district military during slightest 10 days prior to a eventuality is held.

The military contingency afterwards surprise a owners of a public venue inside of twenty-four hours as well as a latter contingency jot down its objections or concerns to a military inside of 48 hours of receipt.

These objections or concerns, a Act says, contingency be taken in to care when a police, underneath territory 15, list their conditions down to a convene organisers for a pronounced event.

But should a list of military conditions be violated, territory fifteen outlines a limit RM10,000 fine as punishment, whilst sections 20 as well as 21 allows a military to, without warrant, detain any organiser or participant, as well as emanate any order to sunder a event.

Section 11 of a Act additionally states which a convene organiser "shall obtain a agree of a owners or occupier of a place of public for it to be used for a role of a assembly".

The Act does not, however, outline any punitive action should territory 11 be violated.

DBKL has prohibited Bersih from regulating Dataran Merdeka this Saturday. KL Mayor Tan Sri Ahmad Fuad Ismail in jeopardy yesterday to "forcefully bar" Bersih 3.0 participants from a venue should they demand upon regulating it for a rally.

"If there is chaos, blame Bersih," he said.

Read More @ Source

More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |

Courtesy of Bonology.com Politically Incorrect Buzz & Buzz