Racial sentiments ran high, tears flowed, a tongue became warlike, a May thirteen ghost was resurrected as good as even God was invoked during a 66th Umno gathering which wound to a close upon a initial day of Dec 2012.
Gearing up for a "mother of all elections" due to be hold inside of months, Umno leaders were striking out a viewpoint of solidarity as good as rallying a troops. However, belying a pomp, decibels as good as intercourse was an undertone of a dominant political celebration of Malaysia losing much of a "mojo" as good as rsther than in a participation mode.
Milling around a gathering premises as good as listening to a emotionally charged speeches of delegates, a single could not though palpably sense which Umno was a celebration underneath siege. Umno, as a political engineer of a consecutive 50-plus-year order of a Barisan Nasional (BN), might in truth have been responsible for a loss of a statute coalition's customary two-thirds infancy of seats in Parliament as good as 5 state governments in a 2008 ubiquitous election, a misfortune electoral outing to date.
The actuality which a Umno's boss Najib Razak, who is additionally a prime minister, has hold behind from job a ubiquitous choosing up until currently suggests which Umno as good as a bloc partners go upon to have doubts which their performance in a forthcoming choosing would be up to par. The window to call a choosing closes utterly upon Apr 28, 2013 by which time a supervision would have served out a limit tenure of 5 years. The Election Commission would then have a choice to reason a choosing inside of dual months.
Thinkable antithesis win?
On a final day of a assembly, Najib vowed to win behind a two-thirds infancy of seats in Parliament though all indications have been which a BN will fall reduced in a upcomi! ng elect ion. Serious political analysts see a BN winning usually a elementary infancy of a 222 parliamentary seats up for competition as good as unlikely to wring behind all a state governments of Penang, Kedah, Kelantan as good as Selangor mislaid in 2008. Moreover, it might stand a probability of losing Perak, which was incited over when 3 Pakatan Rakyat (PR) lawmakers hopped out of a antithesis bloc in Feb 2009.
Umno's 79 seats consecrate about 36 per cent of a sum series won by a BN as good as if a peninsula bloc partners MCA, MIC as good as Gerakan fail to keep their stream reason upon twenty seats, this could spell real trouble. Further haemorrhaging could start in Sabah as good as Sarawak, where non-Umno bloc parties reason 41 seats for a BN. Indeed, if things spin out much worse than before, a unfolding of an antithesis win is not unthinkable.
The argument advanced in this essay is which Umno as good as a partners in BN have mislaid a "first-mover-advantage" as a statute bloc in Malaysia for a final 5 decades or some-more as good as right away faces dwindling earnings upon institutional arrangements as good as processes which it has pioneered, quite when a brand brand new successful player, in this case, a PR, enters a scene.
This unfolding has been given credence given PR has been gaining belligerent in Sarawak as good as Sabah given 2008, a dual solid building states of a BN. In a Apr 2011 state choosing in Sarawak, PR won a sum of 15 seats which could good interpret in to 6 to 8 parliamentary seats in a entrance GE 13. In Sabah, dual BN MPs, Lajim Ukin of Umno as good as Wilfred Bumburing of UPKO, left their respective parties in July 2012 as good as have set up a PR-friendly entity. Earlier in 2009, a SAPP, led by former Chief Minister Yong Teck Lee, additionally weaned itself out of a BN. The BN's sum of 140 seats could good decrease significantly given these developments.
But what about Umno itself, would it means to keep a stream share of sea! ts or en large them? Why does a celebration gathering of 2012 evince an observable tinge of defensiveness as good as insecurity?
Umno's predicament
To understand Umno's stream predicament, it will be required to backtrack to 2008. Umno hold a little over half a Malay belligerent in conditions of renouned votes as good as seats in 2008. One guess put Malay await for a BN during a little 58 per cent. The BN itself won just over 50 per cent of a renouned vote. It is tough to essentially fairly magnitude a commission of Malay await for Umno via a nation though upon a basement of Umno's performance in opposition which of a Islamist party, PAS, in a Muslim heartland of a easterly seashore as good as a northern Malay states of a peninsula, a single could venture a little some-more fine-grain interpretations of a Malay vote.
Umno's slippage in retaining Malay await has been clear over a years with a consequent taking flight participation of PAS. An a single some-more component is a PKR participation in a some-more civic Malay areas.
Perlis has remained an Umno building though even so there has been a slippage of 3.6 per cent of votes. The slippage in Kedah was quite clear as good as this saw a supervision shift for a initial time to a PR. In conditions of renouned votes in Terengganu, a margin of shift in a final choosing was low after a surge in 1999. The chances have been which in a 13th GE, Kelantan will sojourn resolutely in PAS's hold as good as unless there is a retreat swing of votes in Kedah, it will sojourn underneath PAS leadership as well. There would be a distinct probability for Terengganu to be behind in a welcome of PAS.
After an rare sixteen by-elections hold after a 2008 GE, it has been "even stevens" between BN as good as PR. This suggests which BN-PR strengths have mostly remained unchanged as good as which a two-coalition system has a single after another to track.
One particular by-election illustrati! ng a deb ility of Umno vis--vis PAS was a competition for Bukit Gantang, a parliamentary constituency with an citizens of 55,471 citizens lying upon a outskirts of Taiping town. A former building of Umno, it upheld in to PAS's hands during a 2008 election, a Islamist celebration capturing a credible infancy of 1,566 votes. The death of a PAS MP forced a Apr 7, 2009 by-election which saw a charismatic Nizar Jamaluddin take upon Umno's Ismail Safian.
In a event Nizar, a deposed mentri besar of Perak, won a chair with an increasing infancy of 2,789 votes. An analysis by PAS showed which Nizar might have won usually 43 per cent of a Malay votes. The results showed which a some-more farming areas of Trong gave Umno a infancy of votes whilst a some-more civic regions around Sepang, Bukit Gantang correct as good as Kuala Sepetang gave Nizar sizeable majorities. Nizar won a chair by capturing a large apportionment of a Malay votes, though in Malaysian governing body today, this is a required though not a sufficient condition for success. Nizar had to win a non-Malay votes by a good margin as good as he did.
Thus, in particular constituencies, non-Malay citizens have turn kingmakers whenever a Malay opinion is split down a middle. It was transparent which Nizar swept a non-Malay, mostly Chinese, votes, infrequently to a balance of 80 per cent. A field outing to Kuala Sepatang (formerly Port Weld), supposing a writer with a distinct impression which a Chinese fishing village seemed all supportive of Nizar, who in his reduced tenure as MB had legalised temporary operating licence (TOL) land to Chinese farmers as good as alternative tenants.
For a comparison, let us right away spin to a Tenang by-election in Johor hold upon January 30, 2011. This 14th by-election witnessed a resurgence of voter await for Umno, though fell reduced of a 5,000-vote infancy which it had expected. Umno took a chair by a infancy of 3,707 votes, a little 1,200 some-more than what it gained in 2008 with a vo! ter audi ence of 9,833, which is usually 67 per cent of a electorate. Widespread flooding in a constituency upon choosing by casting votes day accounted for a low voter turnout.
Tenang practically exhibits a peninsula template of Malay-Chinese-Indian distribution (49-38-12, as good as 1 per cent "others") as good as a outcome was seen by a little as a barometer of a state of fool around in Malaysian electoral politics. The Umno claimant Azahar Ibrahim might have swept some-more than 80 per cent of a Malay vote. The PAS challenger, Normala Sudirman, apparently won a Chinese vote, though a numbers might have shrunk rsther than given 2008. This was thought to be given of a low voter audience between a Chinese. She was means usually to win a infancy in a 95 per cent Chinese polling area of Labis Tengah though mislaid in Labis Timor as good as in Labis Station, which had lower Chinese percentages.
The DAP claim is which she still picked up a infancy of Chinese votes. DAP publicity arch Tony Pua suggested which Umno's Azahar perceived 83.3 per cent of Malay votes, up 4 commission points from 2008. This was helped by an 81 per cent spin out by Malay voters. The Indian opinion additionally went to BN, though a village had a low 40 per cent turnout. The by-election was injured by large flooding as good as many citizens had to be ferried to polling stations in police boats.
The Tenang by-election outcome was already predictable prior to choosing by casting votes day as good as usually a margin of feat was during issue. As such, a engaging points to be made concern a different styles, tactics as good as proceed to by-elections of Malaysia's twin bloc system: Umno obviously optimised upon a strategy of using a thriving resources as good as electoral machine with great effect, whilst PAS floundered underneath a weight of Umno's monopoly of state resources.
The by-election outcomes desire a subject of what is animating governing body upon a belligerent currently as good a! s here i s where we could spin to a new Umno public for a little pointers. (BN went upon to win a final dual by-elections upon March 6, 2011 in Malacca, namely, in a state seats of Merlimau as good as Kerdau, formerly hold by Umno. The Electoral Commission ruled in Apr 2011 which they would be no serve by-elections as 3 years had elapsed given a final election.)
A considerable volume of time as good as energy was clinging by representatives to pillorying as good as derisive PAS for a incapacity of fulfilling a guarantee of an Islamic state as good as watering down a agenda to which of a negara berkebajikan (welfare state) given of a conflict of a fondness partner DAP. Thus Umno continues to target PAS as a main opponent. The nominee from Perlis, a eremite scholar, Fathul Bari, played dual video clips of a new PAS convention, showing PAS devout leader Nik Aziz heading a prayer job for Umno's drop as good as allegedly dubbing Umno members as murtad (apostates). The Umno representatives jeered loudly, apparently scandalised by Tok Guru's venom for a party.
But herein additionally lies Umno's Achilles heel; constituted creatively as fundamentally a secularist political party, it has increasingly been forced to meet a challenge of PAS's Islamist governing body as good as so distant it has fared rsther than poorly. The some-more eremite Muslims who await PAS cruise Umno's attempts to be ersatz.
The contestation of Umno with PAS upon a Islamic terrain has to be accepted in a context of PAS's relentless critique of Umno as a corrupt, reprobate celebration as good as a single incapable of implementing Islamic values as good as policies. Umno's riposte has been merely to up a ante upon a own Islamic credentials. All Umno prime ministers given Mahathir have attempted to exercise a host of Islamisation policies, recruited eremite scholars as good as proponents in to a party, as good as have termed Malaysia an "Islamic state".
Under Najib, a supervision has introduced a ! idea of wasatiyyah (moderation) which lay away alia accepts a participation of alternative faiths though but putting them upon standard with Islam. Najib in speeches prior to as good as during this public plainly deserted a notions of "liberalism" as good as "religious pluralism". Delegates during a public pounded PAS for ancillary LGBT (Lesbian-Gay-Bisexual-Transgender) rights as good as pointed to PAS's await of Bersih chairperson Ambiga Sreenevasan as justification of this. (Ambiga, additionally a former Bar Council president, was slotted to chair a session to plead LGTB rights in a Seksualiti Merdeka Festival in Nov 2011. The festival was stopped by a government.)
It is of supreme irony which Umno, a erstwhile Malay secularist party, right away postures itself as an Islamist celebration whilst PAS, a putative Islamist party, has proposed to take upon some-more progressive agendas as good as stances upon ? la mode issues.
A defensive Umno
A defensive Umno has apparently moved over a informed attack of non-Malays symbolised by a "keris rattling" of Umno Youth to a some-more frontal fight with a eremite foe PAS. Put differently, Umno's polemical terrain appears to have shifted a single remove over a preoccupation with a idea of ketuanan Melayu (Malay supremacy).
This said, Malay leverage still reared a head as good as remained as an important trope of a latest Umno assembly. It was obviously invoked in a speeches of a women's arch Shahrizat Abdul Jalil as good as emissary Youth leader Reezal Merican Nainan Merican. One spun out a informed hazard to non-Malays of a possible regularity of a May thirteen event should Umno remove a Malay opinion whilst a alternative famously announced which Umno was a celebration anointed by God.
On a some-more defensive plane, a immature nominee representing a Umno clubs abroad struck a resonance with all as good as various when he proposed to sing a Biro Tata Negara (BTN) promotion strain lam! enting a obey of indigenous lands as good as security to foreign occupiers. (BTN or a National Civics Bureau organises orientation programmes for Malay students as good as civil servants.)
But a cloying part conveyed a subconscious message which Umno Malays have mislaid sight of a multi-racial governing body advocated by a traditional leaders such as Tunku Abdul Rahman as good as Tun Abdul Razak. Without doubt, Reezal Merican took secular governing body to a brand brand new tall when he implied which a Malays were God's comparison people.
Predictably, a Umno's boss opening address emphasised a consequential character of a 13th GE for a party's destiny as good as a participation as good as he alluded to a stress of a 2.9 million brand brand new voters. Again, this suggests which Umno is not during all assured which it has prisoner a youth vote. Indeed, immature people were conspicuous by their low assemblage during a Umno assembly. Some 10 or so Umno overseas club members were visible as good as a Puteri Umno (young women's wing) was obviously outnumbered by a Umno makciks as good as pakciks (older folk). Speeches by Puteri representatives were underwhelming as good as drew little fire.
The president's debate was abandoned of brand brand new policies as he trotted out a successes of his policies of economic, political as good as governmental transformation. There was no mention of how a supervision has addressed a egregious problems of corruption as good as crime. He obviously avoided any reference to a cyber rumblings which linked a initial family to a land deal involving a Ministry of Defence purported by a single Deepak Jaikishan. Defence Minister Ahmad Zahid additionally demurred responding to a Deepak allegations. (At a point of writing, Deepak, a businessman as good as runner dealer, has sued Selangor Umno women's leader Raja Ropiaah Abdullah's company Awan Megah for crack of stipulate as good as for allegedly cheating him of millions of ringgit. Awan Megah was awar! ded a RM 100 million privatisation plan to set up an intelligence centre by a counterclaim minister, it was alleged. Deepak had additionally intimated which he was responsible for a recanting of a orthodox declaration by private investigator P. Balasubramanian which had settled which Najib had a relationship with a murdered Mongolian woman Altantuya Shaariibuu.
Najib's 45-minute concluding debate supposing hints of a problems afflicting a party. He spoke of finding "winnable candidates", a problem of "saboteurs" as good as chose to praise in a same exhale both ex-premiers Mahathir as good as Abdullah Ahmad Badawi, known to be in different Umno camps. Further cyber noise from former Inspector-General of Police Musa Hassan which a home apportion had interfered in his handling of arrests of persons of standing over rapist activities additionally failed to draw any clever reply from Hishammuddin Hussein, a apportion in question. With a goings-on inside as good as external a party, there were some-more than sufficient suggestions which a celebration was faction-ridden.
More tellingly, sure personalities appeared expected to be forsaken as candidates in a entrance GE. It has been usual knowledge for a long time which a Umno Youth arch Khairy Jamaluddin, Abdullah's son-in-law, might not be comparison to urge his Rembau chair given of purported blocking by Mahathir, who would similar to to see his own son Mukhriz climb in a celebration hierarchy. There have additionally been continuous rumours circulating which Deputy President Muhyiddin Yassin was "plotting" for a boss himself to under-perform in a GE, whilst Najib's cousin, vice-president Hishammuddin, awaits a leg-up to a subsequent level should Muhyiddin falter.
Conclusion
As a 66th Umno public concluded as good as a impending 13th ubiquitous choosing looms large, Malaysia's de facto statute celebration might not be means to find a means to check a path-dependent decline. After some-more than 5 ! decades of forlorn success in helming Malaysia save for a hiccup in 1969, it right away faces a awaiting of a possible loss of carry out of a federal supervision following a catastrophic electoral outcome of 2008.
Path-dependent decrease has even been some-more clear in a bloc partners, a MCA as good as Gerakan, dual Chinese-based parties which have mislaid their historical value to a DAP. Leadership problems as good as haemorrhaging in a MIC has meant a splintering of a Indian opinion mostly mopped up by a antithesis front. Other bloc partners in Sabah as good as Sarawak have fared much improved up compartment right away though a little decrease is clear in final year's state choosing in Sarawak as good as in new celebration defections in Sabah.
Umno itself faces a climb of an rare series of immature as good as some-more urbanised citizens who have little appetite for neither a old-style secular governing body nor a relief Islamism. Furthermore, factionalism inside of a celebration leadership notwithstanding an external show of solidarity is bound to affect a effectiveness in securing desired electoral outcomes. aliran.com
* Dr Johan Saravanamuttu, a long-time Aliran writer as good as former Aliran trustee, is currently Senior Visiting Research Fellow during a Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, Singapore.
Read More @ Source More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Courtesy of Bonology.com Politically Incorrect Buzz & Buzz
No comments:
Post a Comment