And thus democracy makes cowards of us all Farish A. Noor



The older you get, the grumpier as well as some-more cynical you become; as well as as you grow some-more cynical by the day, zero gets my goat some-more than carrying to watch as well as review about the developments in Malaysia where the lowest common denominator manners the day.
On this arise you find myself riled once again by the renouned as well as populist direct for vernacular education, as well as to contend the multi-track preparation complement in the country. Again as well as again this emanate bedevils our inhabitant politics, as well as again as well as again most, if not all, of the domestic parties in the republic fall back to their protected positions whilst banking upon what they courtesy as their healthy as well as protected domestic constituencies.
In this courtesy both the ruling coalition as well as the antithesis coalition appear to be equally at fault: Neither side seems prepared to take the longhorn by the horns as well as do what seems simply required if you still starting to perform the idea which there is some form of nation-building at work in this country. Malaysia boasts of the uniqueness, though in this the single courtesy it does appear to be unaccompanied indeed.
After some-more than half the century of independence you still adhere upon to the idea which an inclusive inhabitant account can come about through not one, though multiform vernacular preparation systems. Nowhere else in the universe (or the developed universe at least) can you consider of an example of such an arrangement, where both the government as well as the antithesis appear prone to support the renouned direct for vernacular-based preparation streaming.
Nowhere else in the universe would the plural multitude be made all the some-more alienated from itself by permitting kids to investigate in the c! ompany o f those who have been some-more cultura! lly as w ell as linguistically closer to them.
We lament, as you often do, the declining levels of inter-ethnic hit in the country; as well as you bewail which the supposed 'golden years' of Malaysia in the 1950s as well as 1960s have been prolonged gone. And nonetheless you contend this inane idea which by segregating young kids from an early age along linguistic-cultural lines you can still forge the Malaysian nation, together. How? And upon what basement would which common clarity of inhabitant belonging be found?
We consternation how as well as why the eremite functionaries in the republic can have the pronouncements they do, though what do you design if you concede the condition where young kids from the same linguistic-cultural credentials have been kept in the association of people identical to them from primary to delegate education, as well as maybe even beyond?
I have said the same thing so many times by right away which you am usually thankful which the internet does not incur the rubbish of ink as well as paper: Yet today, in Malaysia, it is conceivable which the kid of the sold linguistic-cultural organisation grows up in the association of identical young kids up to the age of 18, without ever carrying to shake hands with someone of the opposite ethnic, linguistic or eremite background. So most for farrago afterwards - how upon earth can you design Malaysians to confederate if the tutorial complement keeps them detached for so long?
And whilst upon the subject of comparisons, can you suppose the identical situation in any developed country, like the UK, Germany or France? Where would France as well as Germany's minorities be if they were segregated from childhood in Arabic or Turkish schools?
How could they hope to come in the mainstream of multitude which is still defined as well as made by the inhabitant language! of thos e countries? On the contrary, whilst you was vital in Germany you came across scores of German-Arab as well as Turks who wante! d their kids to come in as well as attain in the mainstream tutorial system, meaningful which in which republic which is the usually trail to higher education, as well as possible upward amicable mobility as well.
Yet what it takes for this to happen in Malaysia is domestic bravery as well as the will to put brazen radical proposals which might not be popular, in fact officious unpopular. It takes the politician with bravery to contend which Malaysian kids ought to be means to meet, study, compete as well as attain in the unaccompanied inhabitant tutorial complement which mirrors the being of Malaysia's plural as well as formidable society.
And it takes some bravery to state which if any Malaysian parent wishes his or her kid to investigate Mandarin or Tamil, he should be means to do so in the same unaccompanied inhabitant drill complement where these languages should additionally be taught as Malaysian languages languages which have been spoken in the region for centuries.
But politicians lend towards to be shy in the face of approved populism, as well as the will of the voter no matter how uninstructed, how hypocritical or inequitable seems to hold lean over their own opinions. you have met politicians upon both sides of the blockade who have confided in me their fears as well as anxiety over where the nation-building process in Malaysia is heading, as well as who know which if this direction continues there will not be the single Malaysia though multiform Malaysias, which live side by side though sojourn clueless about their neighbours. But these really same politicians appear serf to the ballot box as well as paralysed when it comes to you do what is necessary, despite unpopular. They cannot verbalise out for fright of losing their supposed 'natural opinion bases', which happen to be racial as well as linguistic opinion bases, reflective of our fractured society. And so the charade continues, as well as you sojourn the republic which studies, as well as lives, apart.
Thus h as Populist Democracy made cowards of us all?
* Dr Farish A. Noor is the comparison fellow at the Nanyang Technological University, Singapore.
Read More @ Source



More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Courtesy of Bonology.com Politically Incorrect Buzz & Buzz

No comments: