MCA by a Young Professionals Bureau Chief, Datuk Chua Tee Yong, held a fifth press discussion yesterday, seventeen Jul 2012, in a stability attempt to lift allegations of impropriety by a Pakatan Rakyat Selangor Government in entering in to a Settlement Agreement with Talam Corporation 2 years ago.
MCA in a latest press discussion right away alleges which a Selangor Government is "shifting goalpost" in answering Chua Tee Yong's allegations.
FALLACIES IN MCA'S ARGUMENTS
MCA as well as Datuk Chua Tee Yong should gangling a open from suffering serve insults to their comprehension by ceasing their treasonable arguments upon this issue. When reviewed logically, a fallacies as well as fake arguments have been plain for all to see. Fallacies have been fake or fake arguments employed by a intellectually dishonest to provide a fake end which proves zero when a fallacies have been finally exposed.
HALF-TRUTHS
Half-truth is a misconception of revelation a truth yet upon purpose omitting critical details in order to falsify as well as await a fake conclusion. The initial misconception in MCA's arguments is a make make use of of of half-truths, whilst upon purpose self-denial element facts. MCA has upon purpose withheld a following element facts:
a) That MCA failed to disclose a debts were incurred during a BN administration department of a Selangor Government;
b) That a Pakatan Rakyat Government acted to recover RM392 million debts due by Talam to Kumpulan Darul Ehsan, Permodalan! Negeri Selangor Berhad as well as Yayasan Pendidikan Selangor in connection with several property growth projects carried out in a last 10 years;
c) That a BN Selangor State Government allowed Talam to catch a debts during a time 3 MCA representatives were Selangor EXCO members;
d) That a BN/MCA state government allowed a state GLCs as well as agencies to enter in to highly questionable exchange in which Talam was given land as care for contracts before Talam had even completed a part of a contracts;
e) That a BN/MCA state government did not take any movement to pick up a debts to a extent Talam in a 2007 Annual Accounts did not consider a debts as stream liabilities yet instead treated them as prolonged tenure payables;
f) That a BN/MCA state government failed, not asked and/or refused to take any movement or correct movement to pick up a debts:
> Even after Talam was declared to be an influenced issuer pursuant to Practice Note 17/2005 of a Bursa Malaysia Listing Requirements upon 1 Sep 2006;
> Even yet Talam had accumulated losses of RM446.53 million, as during 31 Jul 2008 with sum borrowings of RM1.184 billion of which RM924.8 million or 78.1% of a sum borrowings were in default;
> Even yet Talam was incompetent to pay a debts when due since it had over RM2 billion in debt as well as traffic payables whereas a receivables as well as money was less than RM280 million;
g) That a debts were not cumulative as well as upon a winding-up of Talam, a preferred as well as cumulative creditors would have priority over a state as well as alternative unsecured creditors;
h) That Talam had due a restructuring devise to solve a defaulted debts by issuing assorted forms of welfare shares as well as loan batch to a lenders which released a state GLCs as well as agencies;
i) That a Securities Commission had by a minute dated twenty-five Sep 2007 deserted Talam's Proposed Regula! rization Plans; and
j) That there were assorted petitions filed by several creditors for a winding-up of companies in a Talam Group.
MCA has withheld a upon top of report from a open in their press conferences. It is clear to those who have checked a publicly accessible report such as Talam's open announcements upon a settlement, a annual reports as well as circulars to shareholders which a Pakatan Rakyat State Government would not be means to recover any cash. The receiving of a thirteen pieces of land was a most appropriate accessible choice in a circumstances.
LYING WITH STATISTICS
Another usual fake evidence is fibbing with statistics. This is using true total as well as numbers to "prove" unrelated claims. MCA has lied with census data by focusing usually upon 1 out of thirteen pieces of land. MCA in alleging which a State Government had given an extreme worth of RM181,082,000.00 for a Bestari Jaya land when a marketplace worth is RM139,090,000.00 failed to apply a correct census data which is, which a Menteri Besar as well as a Selangor Government had taken back thirteen pieces of land with a sum marketplace worth of RM685,230,000.00 for a care of usually RM676,094,000.00.
In any event, MCA did not disclose which in a same document disclosing a marketplace worth as well as a care worth of a Bestari Jaya land, a book worth was RM215,128,000.00 as well as therefore Talam suffered a book loss of RM34,046,000.00. MCA's allegation which Talam was means to come to terms "a good deal" is therefore but substance.
PLAYING ON EMOTIONS
Playing upon emotions is a classic misconception of ignoring facts as well as calling upon emotions alone. MCA in alleging which a "debt free" Permodalan Negeri Selangor Berhad (PNSB) is right away saddled with a RM230 million debt in shopping 2 of a Talam resources from a Selangor Pakatan Rakyat Government is invoking emotions wh! ilst ign oring a fact which it was a BN/MCA administration department which saddled a Selangor GLCs as well as agencies with a RM392 million complaint in a initial place.
CLEAN HANDS
It is a well-established principle which "he who comes to equity contingency come with clean hands". MCA is precluded from questioning a Pakatan Rakyat Government's efforts to recover a Talam debts but MCA initial purging themselves by receiving a appropriate movement opposite their Selangor EXCO members who permitted such debts to be incurred in a initial place as well as had failed, refused and/or not asked to pick up a debts.
THE BIG LIE
The large distortion technique is a ? la mode misconception of repeating a distortion or fake half-truth over as well as over, quite in a media, until people believes it but serve proof or evidence. MCA in repeating their unfounded allegations opposite a Pakatan Rakyat Selangor Government in 5 press conferences after explanations have been put forth by a Menteri Besar as well as others have been putting in to make use of a important allude to by Joseph Goebbels:
"If you tell a distortion large sufficient as well as keep repeating it, people will in a future come to hold it. The distortion can be confirmed usually for such time as a State can shield a people from a political, mercantile and/or troops consequences of a lie. It to illustrate becomes undeniably critical for a State to make make use of of all of a powers to repress dissent, for a truth is a mortal rivalry of a lie, as well as to illustrate by extension, a truth is a biggest rivalry of a State."
It is also a usual misconception befalling those who hold which it is necessary to continue upon a wrong course of movement after finding which it is a mistake since of a fright which by revelation a mistake, there would be unthinkable consequences to his leadership.
The fallacies of these ! "big lie " technique as well as Goebbels' didactic discourse had been unprotected upon Nov 19, 1863, during a loyalty rite of a troops tomb during Gettysburg which "you cannot fool all of a people all of a time".
INTELLECTUAL HONESTY
It is hard to find a more sleepy as well as intellectually dishonest evidence even in Malaysian governing body currently than MCA's stability allegations of impropriety opposite a Pakatan Rakyat for recuperating a Talam debt in a vain hope of attracting domestic await in Selangor. This episode is a clear indication which MCA is not interested in vocalization honestly to Malaysians. If MCA is sincere in helping a people of Selangor, afterwards it should help in converting a thirteen pieces of Talam land in to money for a people's benefit.
There have been times as well as events when politicians should stop trying to measure poor domestic points as well as action for a benefit of a people. The tragic events in a State carrying mislaid a resources as well as a difficulty encountered in recuperating a Talam debt is one of this.
If MCA endure with these allegations, let a people judge those who were bustling personification small domestic games whilst a adults were operative sensitively in a critical business of pciking up RM392 million.
William Leong Jee Keen is a PKR Member of Parliament, Selayang
More Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Courtesy of Bonology.com Politically Incorrect Buzz &! ; Buzz
No comments:
Post a Comment