Selangor state assemblymen have been observant red with what appears to be royal involvement in a RUNNING of a State Legislative Assembly.
In July, every state representative allegedy perceived a minute from Sultan Sharafudin Idris Shah, autocratic them to determine to amendments which would supposedly give a Ruler some-more energy over Islamic affairs. (The state assemblymen) say it could have led to a inherent crisis.
The minute was accompanied by a Selangor supervision gazette with due amendments to a Administration of a Religion of Islam (State of Selangor) Enactment 2003.
One representative , who spoke underneath condition of anonymity, pronounced they saw a minute upon their desks during about 9:30am when they attended a Jul eleven state open sitting.
He said,
"We did not know what to do. We were totally shocked. It was a really delicate situation. If we went opposite it, it would have caused a inherent crisis.He combined which if a open had snubbed a minute as great as voted opposite a due amendments, it would have been played to a knob by both a mainstream as great as a Umno-led state opposition.
The Sultan is ostensible to action upon a recommendation of a state government, not a alternative approach around. Even in a counts of Islam as great as Malay culture, a Sult! an has t o action upon a recommendation of a state administration.
WE DIDN'T WANT TO FIGHT THE PALACE. We had request oneself for a palace. WE LET IT PASS."
Phone call from palace
Another assemblyman, who additionally spoke to FMT anonymously, pronounced which a due amendments were initially done available during a state pre-council meeting, a "few days" prior to Jul 11.
According to a state assemblyman:
- Many state assemblymen present during a open were unfortunate with a check as great as hotly debated a details. "They voiced their displeasure during a bill. They felt they should have been consulted first since of a importance.
- The Selangor mufti, state authorised confidant as great as aides to a assorted assemblymen were additionally during a meeting
- Menteri Besar Khalid Ibrahim pronounced he was uneasy by a key of a amendments.
- "The MB requested which a check be kept in duration tentative serve study."
- "The MB asked a officers to leave as great as a assemblymen to stay to discuss a bill."
- Halfway by a discussion, Khalid had to step out to take a call from a palace. Apparently, a displeasure of a state assemblymen had been conveyed to a palace.
- "The MB did not make it clear what a house had said, though a assemblymen took a cue, as great as bargain his (Khalid) predicament, did not aspire to a delay of a bill."
- The Sultan EXCEEDED his powers when he ordered assemblymen to pass a amendments.
- Nevertheless, a BILL WAS PASSED after three readings.
Sultan's Letter to a Selangor State Assemblymen
!
The minute was released from a Alam Shah house in Klang upon Jul eleven as great as has a Sultan's signature upon it.
A duplicate of a minute was since to Free Malaysia Today (FMT) by an unknown sender.
A minute from a Sultan's private secretary, Mohamed Munir Bani, to state open cabinet member Mohamad Yasin Bidin was additionally provided to FMT.
It reads:
"I respectfully present a decree of His Majesty a Sultan of Selangor to be distributed to all Selangor State Assemblymen immediately."The due amendments would:
A Pakatan Rakyat leader, who asked to sojourn anonymous, additionally pronounced he suspected which Umno had pushed a house said,
"The Sultan has been advised by Umno for 50 years. This put His Majesty in a really difficult situation. This was a ploy by Umno to put Pakatan during loggerheads with a Sultan.He defended a Sultan as an "objective" person, though pronounced Mohamad Munir, being pro-Umno, had done it difficult for Khalid to get an audience.
Sungai Panjang state representative Mohamed Khir Toyo claimed ignorance of a matter, whilst Seri Serdang representative as great as state antithesis personality Mohamad Satim Diman could not be contacted.
RELATED ARTICLE
Selangor Sultan Over Stepped Constitutional Boundaries, says Law Expert Aziz Bari
The Selangor Sultan might have overst! epped hi s powers by autocratic state assemblypersons to pass a Bill behind in July, pronounced Universiti Islam Antarabangsa (UIA) law highbrow Abdul Aziz Bari.
He pronounced this when asked to criticism upon a decree sealed by Sultan Sharafudin Idris Shah, ordering them to pass a slew of amendments to EXPAND a powers of both a SULTAN as great as Selangor Islamic Religious Council (Mais) over Islamic affairs in a state.
The decree, antiquated Jul 11, a duplicate of which was since to Malaysiakini was attached with a minute sealed by a sultan's in isolation secretary, Mohamed Munir Bani.
To AVOID another confrontation with a palace, Pakatan Rakyat lawmakers! COMPROM ISED as great as PASSED a amendments to a Administration of a Religion of Islam (State of Selangor) Enactment 2003, although they saw it as a form of ROYAL INTERVENTION with a STATE LEGISLATURE.
!
Sinc e receiving over a state supervision in March 2008, Pakatan has been during loggerheads with a house over several issues.
Constitution Does NOT Provide Sultan with a Powers
Aziz, an expert in inherent counts as great as have combined during length upon a purpose of a monarch, pronounced a constitution might not provide a sultan such powers.
He pointed out which nonetheless a Federal Constitution - Article 3(2) as great as Section 1(2)(d) of a Eighth Schedule - clearly states which a sultan can action though or opposite a supervision upon counts pertaining to Islam as great as Malay customs, it was SILENT upon a part of a legislature.
Aziz Bari said,
"While upon Islamic counts a sultan might ignore a supervision advice, a same might NOT be applicable when it comes to a legislature.Selangor Sultan's Demands for Amendments to a Selangor state law removes Selangor's Islamic Religious Council (MAIS) Accountability to a State Government.
We have been NOW traffic with a legislative energy over which a supervision CANNOT control. In actuality a supervision is subservient - or answerable - to it.
The sultan is usually giveaway from government, but which does NOT meant which he (Sultan) is additionally giveaway from a House.
Nonetheless interference in such petty matters, could make a monarchy, which ought to be detached as great as symbolic, embroiled or caught in mundane as great as routine matters, thus putting a firmness during stake.
It is only as great much as great as would imperil a firmness of a palace; generally after what happened in Perak as great as Selangor after 2008.The fright is a powers might be exercised by some alternative parties.
For a single thing a sultan might be as great busy as great as this might lead to a incident where sure parties step in underneath his name.
Given that, what will occur to his purpose as great as position as a father figure of a state?"
Some of a amendments which give Mais a energy to pick up as great as discharge zakat as great as fitr! ah as gr eat as giveaway a council's account from being audited by a Auditor-General, were simply receiving a reverse direction opposite calls for greater accountability.
Perhaps we can look at! a single exa mple - a state awards. Although a constitution acknowledges a energy of a sultan, it additionally creates it compulsory to get a consent of a legislative open should this have a monetary implication.
It (the amendment) can free a bodies endangered from scrutiny as great as this is bad from a inherent point of view."
Another debate which has arisen from a amendments, is giving Mais a authority to discharge mosques as great as suraus, together with a energy to designate mosque officials as great as to approach a duties of mosque committees.
There have been utterly most mosques as great as suraus which have been built by a peoplehttp://www.blogger.com/img/blank.gif themselves; not from a open purse.
The new sustenance could be used opposite these privately-funded mosques as great as this is not good.
"This is where a position as great as energy of a sultan needs to be seen in a light of Islamic ideals which essentially mount during a really heart of a sustenance concerned."
Read here for more
It's a bitter tablet to swallow for most Selangor assemblymen right away which a government might have lost carry out over a state's Islamic administrat! ive matt ers as great as a estimated tens of millions of ringgit in annual zakat collections.
The amendments done in Jul clearly allowed a state's Islamic Religious Council (MAIS) to be accountable usually to a Sultan of Selangor, Sultan Sharafudin Idris Shah, bypassing a state supervision in a process. T! he amend ments affected a Administration of a Religion of Islam (State of Selangor) Enactment 2003.
Previously, Section sixteen of a Enactment which was upheld during a Jul State Legislative Assembly sitting enabled a executive of Selangor's Islamic Religious Department (JAIS) to be appointed as MAIS's secretary.
The cabinet member would additionally action as a council's arch executive military officer as great as administrator, as great as was responsible for carrying out MAIS's policies as great as resolutions.
However, a Jul amendments took which detail out, as great as allowed a Ruler "on recommendation of a Majlis" (MAIS) to designate a council's secretary.
Speaking underneath condition of anonymity, a state representative pronounced which a changeallowed MAIS to impugn summonses from a State Legislative Assembly's committee.
He told FMT."In a single occasion, MAIS was summoned by a House committee overseeing orthodox bodies as great as subsidiaries.
They refused to crop up upon a drift which they were not theme to a committee."Zakat money
The representative combined which MAIS was a orthodox body combined by a Enactment, as great as had monetary autonomy in a affairs. He said,
"They still have to table their audited accounts prior to a House They can designate their own auditors But they have been not duty-bound to come prior to a committee.With this in tow, MAIS, according t! o an unk nown Pakatan Rakyat leader, could do whatever it wished with a companies though worrying about a state open looking over a shoulder.
The effect of this, politically, is a supervision within a government, as great as Islamic affairs have been taken out of th! e contro l of a state government,. .
This was of special concern, a representative added, since which a amendments additionally gave MAIS a energy to pick up as great as discharge zakat as great as fitrah.
Selangor zakat income came up to about a third of a state government's annual income which was roughly RM1.4 billion."
The Pakatan personality said,
At a process as great as state level, MAIS has six or 7 government-linked companies underneath it They pronounced which a (state) supervision has no common interest in MAIS' corporations.Royal appointments
So they attempted to turn this (to their advantage), by observant which a administration department (of MAIS) is underneath a Sultan
If we lifted a voice (against it), they will raise a emanate of derhaka (betrayal)."
FMT formerly reported which Selangor state assemblymen allegedly perceived a minute from a Sultan during a Jul eleven state open sitting, autocratic them to determine to these amendments.
Caught by warn as great as fearing a constitut! ional cr isis in a event of a refusal, Pakatan state assemblymen ALLOWED a amendments to be upheld though a hitch.
Currently, a Sultan has a energy to designate a MAIS chairman, deputy authority as great as "not fewer than eight alternative members" to a council.
MAIS additionally consists of 5 ex-officio (automatic) members a state secretary, state authorised adviser, state monetary officer, a mufti as great as a arch police officer.According to a unknown state assemblyman, a office building as great as administration department of mosques as great as suraus were additionally affected by a amendments.
JAIS, as great as a state government, he claimed, would have to spend income to set up them, whilst a administration department of these buildings would fall underneath MAIS' purview.
"Now, to set up a mosque or a surau, we have to get capitulation from MAIS Construction of a mosque is underneath JAIS, though a management is underneath MAIS," he said.
Another interesting growth was a erasure of Section 85 of a Enactment.
Provision! s of a S tatutory Bodies Act (Accounts as great as Annual Reports) Act 1980 right away no longer request to MAIS.
No need for audit
According to Malaysian Centre for Constitutionalism as great as Human Rights lawyer K Shanmuga, this meant which MAIS did NOT have! to subm it a accounts to a Auditor-General.
He said,
"The effect of a legislative addition is which a accounts of MAIS (and any alternative orthodox house established by MAIS underneath a Enactment) will no longer have to be audited in suitability with a Audit Act 1957 as great as submitted to a Auditor-General any year.A book review by a proposer of a amendments upheld during a Jul eleven state open sitting was additionally provided to FMT.
In fact, there appears to be no provisions in a Administration of a Religion of Islam Enactment requiring any audit."
In regards to Section 85, it read:
"This section was abolished since a legislature is not enclosed in a definition of 'Statutory Body' in courtesy to a Statutory Bodies (Accounts as great as Annual Reports) Act 1980 [Act 240]."
Posted by Malaysian Unplug
Read More @ SourceMore Barisan Nasional (BN) | Pakatan Rakyat (PR) | Sociopolitics Plus |
Courtesy of Bonology.com Politically Incorrect Buzz & Buzz
No comments:
Post a Comment